Legal Question in Landlord & Tenant Law in California

I was given a 3 Day notice to vacate, what do I do? I could not make my full rent due to lack of work. However, the house that I am renting needs a lot of carpentry work, so the owner propose a deal to me that would benefit both of us and and I would not have to pay rent for 3 months. He sent me an email stating that he was going to sell the house. But, if I would cooperate with the Realtor, took care of the yard and do all repairs to the house, that he would not only forget the back rent due, but that I would not have to pay for a couple of months. The email states. I will pay for your moving expenses, will pay for your first 3 months of rent and will give you the deposit needed for you new place in lieu of your full cooperation in this process and taking care of the repairs. So I sent him several emails asking for an update and when I was getting the materials to start the work, but did not received a reply...and I have held up my end of the deal. So when I sent him the 5th email, he says that he wants us out in 3 days. Is there anything I can do? I was going on false pretenses.


Asked on 7/19/10, 3:01 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Dawn VanHorn VanHorn Legal

You do not indicate if you have a lease, month to month contract or if there was a contract at all for possession of this property. Without that information it is difficult to tell you what each and every one of your remedies might be. However presuming there was some sort of agreement exchanging rental payments for the right to possess the property gives us a starting point.

#1- rent in exchange for possession- You breached the rental contract by not paying the rent as it came due. At this point he had the right to give you a 3 day notice to start the unlawful detainer process. Rather than do that, he approached you with the offer for:

#2-The Landlord approached you with the barter agreement to exchange 3 months of living in the house for your carpentry work on the unit. You don't say if this agreement was via email or if it was oral or if the 3 months of rent were for past due rent or rent moving forward. The landlord then decided to sell the property and emailed you regarding:

#3- The land lord emailed you offering to forgive the back rent, not charge you for 2 months rent moving forward, pay your moving expenses as well as pay the security deposit and first 3 months rent on a new place in exchange for completion of the carpentry work and your full cooperation during the period before the house was sold. If you responded to him in kind (via email) or in any other way the offer requested an acceptance then there is arguably an enforceable contract.

You don't say if the landlord properly served you with the 3 day notice to pay rent or quit, but if all he did was send you an email telling you to get out in 72 hours, that's not proper notice.

In CA he is required to serve the 3 day notice to pay rent or quit if you have violated a lease or month to month tenancy in on of 7 ways, most notably failing to pay rent. Code of Civil Procedure Section 1161(2)-(4). The landlord must also use a very specific notice with the accurate amount of rent due as well as instructions on how you could cure the breach and pay all the back rent due.

Additionally, a 3 day notice must be properly served in 1 of 3 ways:

a. personal service-Code of Civil Procedure Section 1162(1)- a process server must verify your identity and hand you the document;

b. substituted service- Code of Civil Procedure Section 1162(2)- if the process service cannot locate you, but your sister that is over 18 answers the door, he can hand the notice to your sister as a substitute for you or

c. post & mail- Code of Civil Procedure Section 1162(3)- the last option and probably the most used is for the landlord to post the notice on the property in a conspicuous manner and also mail you a copy of that same notice with a proof of service attached. If your landlord didn't do one of those 3 things, you have not received proper notice to vacate the property.

If you have been subsequently served properly with the appropriate 3 day notice to quit then you have 3 days to pay the amount owed or 'quit' the premises (leave). Since you arguably don't owe rent because you have upheld your portion of the 'contract' you have nothing to pay.

The next step is for the land lord to file an Unlawful Detainer lawsuit in Superior Court. The land lord must complete the appropriate form complaint for UD and have the lawsuit served on you in one of the aforementioned ways. Pay close attention to the day you were served because you will only have 5 days to respond to a UD lawsuit and file your answer with the court. UD is a 'summary procedure' which means it is on a very strict timeline in the interests of judicial economy. After you file an answer to the complaint there will be a hearing on the matter within 20 days . This process is very quick in CA- if I were you I would run to the nearest attorney to defend an unlawful detainer suit if you want to stay in the property while you are looking for a new place. You have a good basis to argue that you don't owe the land lord rent and therefore can't be evicted for failing to pay the rent. There is also the possibility that you could sue him for breach of the contract as you certainly didn�t get the benefit of your bargain!

If you don't want to stay in the property and can be out of the house within the time period it will take for all this to happen, then you have a good chance of being able to have your attorney negotiate an amicable exit strategy from the property.

If you are seeking counsel to represent you in this matter, please feel free to contact me via telephone or email. My contact information is listed below.

Thank you for the opportunity to be of service.

Very truly yours,

Dawn R. VanHorn

Attorney & Counselor at Law

VanHorn Legal

(714) 396-4152

[email protected]

www.vanhornlegal.com

www.vanhornlegal.wordpress.com

The foregoing has been written by Dawn R. VanHorn, Attorney & Counselor at Law. If the designated recipient(s) of this communication have not fully executed a retainer agreement engaging Dawn R. VanHorn and/or VanHorn Legal relating to the subject(s) of this electronic message nothing herein constitutes nor is intended to be legal advice and as a result should not be relied upon as such.

The contents of and/or attachments to this communication is intended for the exclusive use of the addressee(s)/author(s) and may contain information that is privileged and confidential or that may be otherwise exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If you have received this message in error do not read or disseminate the following material to anyone other than the intended recipient(s) and please notify Dawn R. VanHorn at (714) 396-4152 immediately as well as email her at this address. Thank you for your cooperation.

Notice concerning IRS Circular 230: Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Rules require me to inform you that this message and any attachment(s) thereto shall not be used for the purpose of avoiding penalties that may be imposed under federal law even if they contain information and/or advice concerning federal taxes. Under the IRS rules, a taxpayer may rely on professional advice to avoid federal tax penalties only if that advice is reflected in a comprehensive tax opinion that conforms to stringent requirements under federal law.

Important notice required by Federal Law: VanHorn Legal is a debt relief agency pursuant to Federal Law �524 of Title 11 of the US Code. We provide legal assistance and help people file for bankruptcy relief under the United States Bankruptcy Code.

Read more
Answered on 7/20/10, 12:22 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Landlord & Tenants questions and answers in California