Legal Question in Family Law in Michigan

Tax exemptions

My divorce decree stipulates which child each of us can claim. Physical custody has since shifted to the other parent and he went ahead and claimed both children for the 2003 tax year. During the 3 years I had physical custody I only claimed the one child as stated in the decree. It was my belief that we had to follow that court order regardless of who had physical custody. He was told that he can claim both children now that he has physical custody, am I wrong in thinking he is in violation of the court order? What recourse do I have after the fact, he has already filed his return, should I submit mine taking the deduction I'm entiltled to? He refuses to file an amendment to his return. Thank you for consideriing this, I look forward to any advice you may give me.


Asked on 2/10/04, 9:40 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

William Stern William Stern, P.C.

Re: Tax exemptions

File it your way and attach the judgment. Bill Stern 248-353-9400

Read more
Answered on 2/11/04, 7:26 am
Henry J. Legere, Jr. Law Office of Henry J. Legere, Jr.

Re: Tax exemptions

It would appear that your ex is entitled to claim the child for the tax year in question. IRS does not consider the language in a divorce judgment to be controlling for who is entitled to claim the dependency exemption. Almost all of the divorce judgments fail to meet IRS standards governing dependency exemptions. Here is the criteria IRS uses to determine who gets the exemption. The support test for the child of divorced or seperated parents depends on meeting all of the conditions listed below.

1. Separated: Parents must be either:

a. Divorced; B. Legally separated; c. Separated under a written separation agreement; or d. Have lived apart at all times for the last six(6) months of the year.

2. Support: One or both parents provide more than half of the child's total support for the calendar year; and

3. Custody: One or both parents have custody of the child for more than half of the calendar year.

DEPENDENCY EXEMPTION: Generally, the parent who has physical custody of the child for the greater part of the year is treated as the parent who provides more than half of the support.

1. Actual support is not the issue; the custodial parent generally is deemed to pass the support test.

2. The divorce decree may not place demands or conditions for the noncustodial parent to receive the exemption; if there are conditions, then first right to claim the child reverts to custodail spouse.

However, there are three exceptions to the above rule as follows:

1. The custodial parent may waive his/her right of the child's dependency exemption by executing a written declaration releasing the exemption right to the noncustodial parent for a year, a number of specified years, or permanently.

-- Form 8332 or a document identical in substance can be used for this purpose [Section 152(e)(2)(A)].

The form is then given to the noncustodial parent, who attaches it to his/her return for each year the dependency exemption is released.

-- A multiple support agreement (Form 2120) is filed that allows the child's dependency exemption to another taxpayer; or

-- In the case of certain pre-1985 instruments, where:

The custodial parent releases, and the noncustodial parent pays at least $600; or The noncustodial parent pays at least $1,200.

Read more
Answered on 2/11/04, 8:34 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Family Law, Divorce, Child Custody and Adoption questions and answers in Michigan