Legal Question in Personal Injury in New York

Insurance company does inadequate investigation

I was involved in an accident that was the other driver's fault clearly(I had right of way).His insurance company fires back stating that they have a witness which states that I was on a cell phone and I ran into the vehicle (both lies).If they would have done an adequate investigation,it would have clearly shown that (a) I had no phone in the car at the time and (2)I did not run into the vehicle(impact on my passenger side rear door mostly).Can the insurance company be sued at this point for it has been 15 months now.


Asked on 10/28/06, 9:28 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

PETER W. YOARS JR. Knox McLaughlin Gornall & Sennett, PC

Re: Insurance company does inadequate investigation

You do not sue the insurance company, you sue the driver of the other vehicle. Is there a witness listed on the Police Accident Report?

If you have suffered serious injuries as a result of this accident, I would be glad to discuss this matter further. Please do not hesitate to contact me.

Read more
Answered on 10/30/06, 9:54 am
David Simon Hogan & Rossi

Re: Insurance company does inadequate investigation

You sue the other driver, and the owner of the vehicle (because the owner is liable by statute for the negligent acts of the driver). You don't have to wait for anything.

When you sue them, their insurance companies will tender a defense on their behalf, and the insurance coverage will be in play (unless they are disclaiming coverage based on some exception).

But more fundamental is that personal injuries sustained in a car accident must satisfy a certain threshold before you can sue. NY's no fault laws only allow you to sue if you have suffered "serious injury". You need to consult a lawyer to find out what that means, because it is the source of much debate and litigation. Certain injuries clearly meet the threshold, but most are in a gray area or insufficient.

If your injury does not meet the threshold, then you are relegated to collect no-fault benefits from your own insurance carrier.

Listen - insurance companies constantly do this. They don't want to pay you. They will try and nickel and dime you and draw the line and dare you to cross it. So assess your case with a lawyer. Most personal injury cases are accepted on a contingency basis anyway. Many times you need to file a lawsuit to get satisfactory results. You have a 3 year statute of limitations, so be mindful of that, but also be mindful that once you start a lawsuit, it may not settle or be resolved for another 1-2 years, so better to sue now rather than later.

Feel free to contact me for a consultation if you wish to discuss it further.

Read more
Answered on 10/28/06, 10:36 pm
Jason A. Richman Jason A. Richman, Esq.

Re: Insurance company does inadequate investigation

I see from your other postings that you have sufered and been treated for injuries suffered in this collision. You should immediately consult with an attorney in your area that is experienced in handling motor vehicle accidents. If you need help finding an attorney with the right qualifications in your area, please feel to contact me and i will point you in the right direction. Consulting with an attorney for a case like this is almost always free, and will be well worth your while.

Read more
Answered on 10/28/06, 10:44 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Personal Injury Law and Tort Law questions and answers in New York