Legal Question in Criminal Law in Arizona
Exclusionary rule
Is the exclusionary rule a constitutional or a judge-made rule? May it be modified by the U.S. congress through legislation?
Asked on 12/08/03, 5:17 pm
1 Answer from Attorneys
Charles Aspinwall
Charles S. Aspinwall, J.D., LLC
Re: Exclusionary rule
If your reference is to the power of courts to suppress or exclude certain evidence in a criminal case from being introduced at trial, the anwer is that the rule is court-created and is, from time to time, modified by the courts, the ultimate authority being the US Supreme Court. Congress could affect the rule by litigation, but does not often delve into the conduct of a trial or the authority of the trial court to determine what is and what is not proper evidence at trial.
Answered on 12/08/03, 8:25 pm
Related Questions & Answers
-
Motion to Change a Felony I was told by the judge when my over-payment was paid and... Asked 12/04/03, 5:46 pm in United States Arizona Criminal Law
-
Dui statue of limitations recieved dui and no proof of ins in az. over 8 years ago,... Asked 11/24/03, 9:13 pm in United States Arizona Criminal Law
-
Honest answer on job application While living in Arizona and married to her first... Asked 11/19/03, 7:07 am in United States Arizona Criminal Law
-
Probable Cause for a Search Warrant For probable cause to obtain and use a search... Asked 11/16/03, 4:27 am in United States Arizona Criminal Law
-
Forgery Our daughter passed away in Arizona 10/24/03. Before we could get the... Asked 11/12/03, 6:47 pm in United States Arizona Criminal Law