Legal Question in Consumer Law in Australia

Yacht offer not accepted but later granted to another offeree

A yacht owner, in a letter to a club said that he will sell his yacht for $80 000 to the first club MEMBER to accept. Letter was read at 7:30pm.

Mr X sent an email accepting the offer at 9:30pm. The yacht owner read the email at 10:00am the next day.

Mr Y posted a letter accepting the offer at 9:00pm and the owner of the yacht received it 2 days later at 3:00pm.

Mr Z, NOT a member rang the yacht owner home offering to pay $90 000 for the yacht. The yacht owner's wife answered the phone saying she had been told to receive any acceptances as he was absent and told Mr Z to call later to arrange delivery.

The yacht owner wants to give the yacht to Mr Z, but Mr X and Mr Y claim the yacht legally belongs to them.

Who does the yacht belong to and what is the law or authority that says this?

Thank you very much


Asked on 4/25/04, 7:36 am

1 Answer from Attorneys

Tim Wishart McMahons National lawyers

Re: Yacht offer not accepted but later granted to another offeree

sorry - it is not the function of this site to answer question for students

Read more
Answered on 4/25/04, 7:46 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Consumer Law questions and answers in Australia