Legal Question in Appeals and Writs in California

Unfair Trial

My son was convicted of 1st degree murder in 1987, he is serving a swentence of 27 yrs to life. He was convicted on circumstantial evidence due to the person he was arrested with (they were both intoxicated and under the influence)giving written statements that my son did a drive by shooting and later at trial the guy said he was coherced into making the statements. Further, the car they were arrested in contained a gun (no fingerprints), and the witness could not identify my son and His girlfriend testified, he was with her at a motel. My son produced the hotel bill and the attorney lost it. When I went to get a copy of that receipt the log book was no longer on file, but the Hotel proprieter remembered my son and testified at trial that He was there the night of the shooting. I believe my son was convicted because of his long arrest record and gang affliation. He is now 40 years old and the crime was commited when he was 22. The case never should have been 1st degree murder and the who actually did the shooting was not established. I believe he has appealed at least (3) times. He serving time at Calipatria State Prison, California. Has had no problems. Help?


Asked on 12/27/04, 11:08 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

James Goff James R. Goff, Attorney at Law

Re: Unfair Trial

It is difficult to reply to your question because it is not clear what kind of help you are seeking. When a person is convicted he is entitled to one appeal. Once he has exhausted his appellate right he must seek relief through a petition for a writ of habeas corpus. The writ of habeas corpus can be sought in both state and federal courts. As with the appeal a person is entitled to only one writ of habeas corpus and the writ of habeas corpus must raise issues that are different from those raised on appeal. If your son has exhausted both his appellate and writ of habeas corpus rights he is strictly limited in the areas he can pursue. You need to discuss these issues with an attorney, who is experienced in criminal appeals. Although through the criminal appeal process your son is entitled to the assistance of an attorney, he is not entitled to the assistance of counsel in the writ of habeas corpus process. In other words either he must file a petition for writ of habeas corpus that raises a significant issue and then seek appointment from the court of the assistance of counsel, or he must retain the assistance of counsel to review his situation and find a basis for habeas corpus relief. Unfortunately, state and federal habeas corpus review is an expensive process. Most attorneys are going to require a substantial retainer to become involved in the process. It is lengthy and time consuming. If your son is unable to retain counsel then he must seek assistance from various programs that provide counsel for those who are innocent or wrongfully convicted. You can seek these organizations on the internet. Sometimes the Prison Union is able to provide assistance. Some law schools will provide assistance. The Innocence Project will entertain cases from prisoners who can convince them that he is innocent. Good luck.

Read more
Answered on 12/28/04, 3:22 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Appeals and Writs questions and answers in California