Legal Question in Business Law in California

1 side breaches a contract if the other also breaches then what ?

Here's what happend. A contract was formed between two parties, where party A lends Party B $1,000 at 10% APR with that 10% minimum amount paied monthly. After 6 months, Party A says to party B ''I now want 20% APR now or I'll ruin your credit'' (pls assume that contract requires mutual consent and that party A's demand is a material breach), .

Because party A breached, party B said, ok then I'm not going to pay the minimum agreement next month because you'll claim that's not enough. So the next month comes and goes and party B doesnt pay, thus breaching the contract. Now both parties are in breach of their own contract. And party B contimplates taking party A to court.

Question - I'm party B, I know I'll have to pay as per the original agreement, but what can I sue for and what can I be counter sued for except the amount I agreed to pay ?

Many thanks,

Charles


Asked on 12/10/04, 3:35 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

Ken Koenen Koenen & Tokunaga, P.C.

Re: 1 side breaches a contract if the other also breaches then what ?

Party A is not in breach. He was demanding more, but you are not required to give it to him. You should just continue making payments. If he attempts to hurt your credit, then you would have a cause of action.

Read more
Answered on 12/10/04, 5:16 pm
Roy Hoffman Law Offices of Roy A. Hoffman

Re: 1 side breaches a contract if the other also breaches then what ?

You should also note that 20% interest is usurious (violating the usury law) in California, so if party A tries to sue you, he likely will not be able to get any more than the original $1,000.00. In fact, 10% per month is likely too high.

Take Mr. Koenen's advice and just continue paying what you agreed to pay. If your credit is damaged you then have claims under multiple state and federal laws.

Read more
Answered on 12/10/04, 5:43 pm
Christopher M. Brainard, Esq. C. M. Brainard & Associates - (310) 266-4115

Re: 1 side breaches a contract if the other also breaches then what ?

Are they a financial institution? First of all, private parties generally can't charge excessive interest -- it is usury and illegal. Futher, it looks like breach of contract, cohersion, black mail, etc. You should tell them to take flying leap and send a copy of their correspondence along with the original contract to the credit agencies to clear your credit if they do try to attack it as threatened. You may retain me if you think it is necessary.

Read more
Answered on 12/10/04, 6:20 pm
Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: 1 side breaches a contract if the other also breaches then what ?

You say to assume it's a material breach -- but it isn't. Party A has fully performed under the simple agreement you describe when he advances you the full $1,000. Having fully performed, his breach is a legal impossibility.

What A has done, rather, is commit the crime of extortion or attempted extortion. In California, by statute, if the demand were put in writing, the crime is complete when the written demand is given to you, whether you submit or not. Otherwise, I think it is only attempted extortion until you submit to the demand.

Returning to breach of contract. When the breach amounts to failure of a "condition precedent," further performance by the non-breaching party is excused. A condition precedent is an act, circumstance, etc. that, under the express or implied terms of the contract, must occur first and triggers a party's duty to perform. In your example, the disbursement of $1,000 in loan proceeds to you is a condition precedent to your duty to make monthly payments to the lender. In your case, the lender has fully performed the contract and cannot breach.

Sure, one might argue that there is a further implied covenant to accept the payments gracefully and not make further demands, but I don't think courts would go that route when there are better legal theories (extortion) available.

Read more
Answered on 12/12/04, 1:50 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Business Law questions and answers in California