Legal Question in Business Law in California
dissolution of business
I and a partner started a caregiving agency business on feb 2006, now, she wants to start her own business...i agreed just so we can separate in good terms but it seems that she demands a lot of things.We never had any written agreement or contract so I understand its 50/50. We both went out and got our new dba. My concern is that when we opened our business together in 2006, we agreed to open 4 mobile lines but it was more difficult to get a company name under cingular so she put it under her name. Now, that we're dissolving the business we have together, she wants to keep the mobile numbers ..I don't think thats fair since I too marketed the business and those numbers were the ones printed on our brochure , business cards, well, everything. I believe those numbers should be dissolved too with the business even though its under her name. The business has been paying for all the phone bills. She always talks about whats fair for her but I'm always the one in the disadvantage. Please help.
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: dissolution of business
First, partnerships don't need written or even oral partnership agreements. Of course, a written agreement is strongly recommended, but lacking an express agreement of any kind, a court can still find an implied agreement, infer its terms from the business conduct of the partners, and enforce it according to those terms.
Whether your partnership is 50-50 (or not) is not an automatic presumption due to lack of an express agreement; if other facts and circumstances showed a different percentage, a court could order a breakup on some other reasonable percentage split according to the evidence. However, a 50-50 determination is most usual.
I agree with you that a split of the partnership assets that gives her the phone numbers is potentially unfair unless you get something in offset. When partnerships are dissolved and wound up, each partner should receive a share of the net assets in relation to his or her capital account, i.e., in most cases, percentage interest in the partnership. To maintain 50-50, you should get something balancing the value of the phone numbers, which may be quite valuable to someone staying in the business.
I don't know if it's worth going to court about, and I don't know if small claims would handle your issues, but you should certainly make your position known to the ex-partner.