Legal Question in Business Law in California
Partnership Dissolution - winding down practices
In a California partnership dissolution, where one of the partners is filing bankruptcy, what is it proper accounting method to wind down the business? In this situation the business has been sold, there are no remaining assests, only debits. The partner filing bankruptcy desires to use debits of the partnership that may be discharged by the bankrupcy, as credit toward their proportion of the debits. Since the largest remaining debit of the business is solely in their name, the idea is that this debit would be discharged through their bankrupcy and since this item is greater than what each partner would owe to reconcile, this partner would be able to walk away from the partnership without any further obligation. Although the other partner may benefit from this situation in that the debits would be less, the other partner feels this is unfair as they initially have more invested into the business and would have to repay the remaining debits on their own. This partner feels that the remaining debit minus the amount to be discharged, should be split evenly. As this would be in the spirit of the partnership and fair for both parties
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Partnership Dissolution - winding down practices
What happened to the proceeds from the sale of the partnership business? If they were NOT used to pay its debts, that was a mistake. No partner should get a dime until all the bills are paid.
There is no special kind of accounting that is especiallyy appropriate to the windup of a partnership, unless perhaps one could say it needs to be "careful" "independent" and "professional."
When a partner of a general partnership becomes bankrupt, that results in dissociation of that partner. See Corporations Code section 16601(6)(A). The partner's dissociation by bankruptcy is usually considered wrongful (Corporations Code section 16602(b)(2)(C)). A wrongfully dissociating partner is not eligible to participate in winding up the partnership business.
The partner's bankruptcy probably will discharge this partner's liability to the other partners and to partnership creditors, but each other partner or former partner should consult bankruptcy counsel for any possibility of lodging a claim in the bankruptcy proceeding on behalf of themselves, or the partnership.
I generally disagree with the notion that any undischarged debt should be split evenly, but this issue would require research beyond by present knowledge and probably should be asked as a bankruptcy law question.
Re: Partnership Dissolution - winding down practices
If your partnership is a general partnership, and one partner files for bankruptcy, the remaining non-bankrupt partners are fully liable, jointly and severally, for the remaining debt.
Also, the creditors can pick and chose which of the non-bankrupt partners (if there are more than one) they can go after to collect. This is called "joint and several liability". To the extent that you would seek to get some of the debt paid by the remaining non-bankrupt partners, you would have to file your own lawsuit against them unless they agreed.
Thus, your issue really isn't one of accounting. It would seem that the best approach is to use the assets of the business to pay down the debt, but this also gets complicated by one partner's bankruptcy, as the partnership interest becomes an asset of the bankruptcy estate, and you would have to get permission of the bankruptcy court to act.
Naturally, we cannot give definitive legal advice without (a) being retained and (b) seeing all of the documentation and getting all of the facts available to you. If you are interested in pursuing this further, feel free to call our office.