Legal Question in Business Law in California

When you sign an engagement contract with an attorney, and there is a clause in there that mentions they can get their "fees" AS WELL AS fees for any "collection matter". What exactly does this mean? If the attorney is fired, and later has to proceed with sueing you for more than his fees, is that a collection matter? What constitutes a valid lien in this case? What kind of lien is it? I can't find any research on this. I'm not sure where to look.


Asked on 10/04/11, 7:31 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

That basically means the lawyer's suit will ask not only for the unpaid fees, but also for the costs associated with collecting the fees. It might be helpful to know that attorney fee suits are regulated by law, and that a client can demand arbitration by a bar association arbitrator or arbitration panel. See Business & Professions Code sections 6200-6206 re arbitration, and 6146-6149.5 re fee agreements generally. Also, the State Bar can answer questions about fee agreements and liens; the only kind of liens I know about are under Family Code sections 2033 and 2034, involving real-estate liens to pay the divorce lawyer. There are also cases where a plaintiff will assign part of his prospective settlement to his attorney to cover the fees, but an assignment creates a different kind of interest - an immediate ownership - rather than a lien.

Read more
Answered on 10/04/11, 8:17 am
Anthony Roach Law Office of Anthony A. Roach

I don't have your retainer agreement/ engagement letter in front of me, but there is another type of lien that Mr. Whipple does not mention. It is called an attorney's charging lien, and is a lien on the recovery you collect or win in the case.

If you have access to a law library, you can read about attorney charging liens in the first chapter of The Rutter Group's Civil Procedure Before Trial. The subject is also covered in The Rutter Group's Professional Responsibility.

There is an entire body of law on the subject, which is governed by the State Bar Act (contained in the Business & Professions Code), case law, and the California Rules of Professional Conduct.

Read more
Answered on 10/18/11, 11:49 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Business Law questions and answers in California