Legal Question in Construction Law in California

mechanic's lien

Can my painter place a mechanics lien on my property if the work he was contracted to do has not been completed (along with a number of other problems)? He has threatened to do so if I do not pay him in full (in addition to some added on fees that were not agreed upon). He is unlicensed (my bad) and ''served'' me with a preliminary notice over 20 days from the time that he started work on my house however he predated it to make it look like he gave it to me earlier (there is no contractor). I can only find information on what to do if someone is licensed, but what rights does he have if he is unlicensed and what rights do I have as a homeowner to protect myself from this guy who's trying to scam me?

Thank you.


Asked on 8/08/07, 8:27 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

Cathy Cowin Law Offices of Cathy Cowin

Re: mechanic's lien

If he is unlicensed you can even sue to get what you've paid returned.

Read more
Answered on 8/08/07, 8:31 pm
Michael Meyer Law Ofc. Of Michael J. Meyer

Re: mechanic's lien

If he's under a direct contract with you (and not through a General Contractor), then no preliminary notice is required (Civil Code 3097).

A mechanics lien arises automatically by his doing work on the house (Civil Code 3110). However, he must perfect the lien by recording it with the county recorders office. Once perfected, he has 90 days to foreclose (Civil Code 3144).

If he adds to his lien claims for work not done or materials not provided, he forfeits the entire lien (Civil Code 3118).

Since he is unlicensed, he does not have standing to sue in California courts (Civil Code 7031). Thus, he cannot foreclose.

Moreover, since he has no standing to present himself in court, you can sue him for breach of contract, object when he tries to defend himself, and maybe even obtain a judgment for the amount of the breach.

If anything, the law is on your side in this matter.

Read more
Answered on 8/08/07, 11:59 pm
EZRA FRUCHTER LAW OFFICES OF E. LEONARD FRUCHTER

Re: mechanic's lien

If the entire contract is more than $500.00, and the contractor is unlicensed, then the contractor is not entitled to come to court. Furthermore, you are entitled to a refund of all monies paid to him. Insofdar as a mechanic's lien, there is no way you can stop him from recording one against the property. However, if he does so, there are several ways to have it removed or cancelled; you need to see a construction attorney for further advice.

Read more
Answered on 8/09/07, 12:47 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Construction Law questions and answers in California