Legal Question in Criminal Law in California
admission of evidence
Prosecution did not introduce written statement of defendant as evidence. The Police officer who took the statement was not called to testify. Prosecution close its case. Defense Counsel commence his case by calling his only witness, the defendant. During Cross-examination of defendant witness, prosecution asked defendant of making a written statement to the Police and defendant responded in the affirmative. Prosecution tried to introduced the written statement, Defense objected that prosecution had his case and never introduced the statement as part of his evidence. Prosecution offered that statement is prior inconsistent statement and should be introduced as impeaching evidence as wells part of substantive evidence of the case. What should the court do?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: admission of evidence
It should tell the person asking the question to do his own homework instead of trying to get someone more knowledgeable to do it for him.
Re: admission of evidence
The court will admit the statement to the police as a prior inconsistent statement. This is the risk you take when the defendant testifies at the trial after talking to the police. The attorney should have known that the statement would be used if the defendant's testimony at trial was materially different the statement.
Related Questions & Answers
-
Arrested for under the influnece of drugs If arrested for under the influence,... Asked 3/26/05, 1:04 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
Felony conviction expungement in california for drug crimes Hello there!! I am... Asked 3/25/05, 2:01 am in United States California Criminal Law
-
Fired for being arrested Can I be fired for a non-related work arrest? The arrest... Asked 3/24/05, 10:22 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
Driving under the influence of a controlled substance this police officer had... Asked 3/24/05, 5:33 am in United States California Criminal Law
-
Three felonies my son already has 2 felonies.he was arrested tonight on child... Asked 3/23/05, 6:08 am in United States California Criminal Law