Legal Question in Criminal Law in California
If you use an animal to kill someone can you be charged with murder?
In a screenplay I want a character to leave a purchased exotic snake(only found on the other side of the world) in someone else's...it might be a toilet, or a sidecar, or a shoe (I'm still deciding)...for the sole purpose of killing the other person. The snake bites and kills the person. The police investigate, find evidence, and charge the character with murder. Sends them to jail for life (or something like that). Is this possible? What would that person be charged with? "First Degree Murder"? "Man slaughter"? I don't understand the terminology haha.
4 Answers from Attorneys
In my book, that's premeditated first-degree murder. There's actually a lawyer here in L.A. who was the victim of such an attack (a rattlesnake, with the rattle removed, was left in his mailbox) but survived.
Search TVTropes.org for 'Animal Assassin'
Since you're the author and can make it whatever you want....
Yes, it's murder. Whether it's a gun, a knife or a deadly poisonous snake, your killer intentionally killed. That's murder. Because it was done in a very well thought-out way, it certainly appears premeditated and therefore first degree murder.
And as a twist - under California Penal Code section 190.2, murder by poison (your DA could make an argument that the snake's poison was just the same as arsenic) is a special circumstance, making the killer eligible for the death penalty.... if you want for your book.
Since the assumption in your facts are that the snake's poison is enough to kill someone, and it supposedly is known to be so venomous, replace the concept of "snake" with "bomb" and you have your answer. However, assuming you are going to make this a story that's more than a few pages long, we'll also assume you are trying to make defenses against the premeditated murder charge, and are looking for gradations of charges.
See the facts of a non-premeditated murder in People of the State of California vs. Marjorie Knoller. Her husband was convicted of involuntary manslaughter, and she was convicted of both the manslaughter charge as well as the second degree murder charge (a huge hit for a negligence dog attack case).
Related Questions & Answers
-
My friend broke into an ilegal marajuana grow house and took all of the weed, and he... Asked 11/26/10, 11:26 am in United States California Criminal Law
-
Can i be subpeopnoed to testify in a criminal case against my ex where i am the... Asked 11/24/10, 2:47 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
I received a citation CA HS 11357(b) in Riverside County. The officer put that it... Asked 11/24/10, 2:06 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
Can I regain money that was taken from me when my home was raided? My case is a DA... Asked 11/24/10, 10:56 am in United States California Criminal Law