Legal Question in Criminal Law in California
My daughter was at a concert in santa cruz. inside the venue a security
guard saw her open a plastic bag which contained a small amount of ecstacy and 2 joints. she was escorted out handed over to the police and charged with 11377(a) & aa357(b). what are the chances of proving an illegal
search and what is the best course of action of getting the 11377
knocked down or dismissed? 2 of her frieds witnesed what happened.
4 Answers from Attorneys
Unfortunately, your fact scenario really doesn't give much information. Based on this limited information though, I can tell you that not good. Because the police had probable cause that the person (your daughter) was engaged in criminal activity.
Here is the bright side, she may be eligible for prop 36, which is a GREAT thing. One, because it allows the defendant to get the charges dismissed once they complete the program and two it has helped a lot of people get off of drugs.
Please feel free to contact me with any questions you may have.
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures - by the government. Private persons, including security guards are not regulated by the same constitutional constraints.
Having said that, as a first offender, she is probably eligible for a drug program to keep this from becoming a conviction on her record. She'll need a good local criminal defense attorney to guide her through this, along with seeing if there are additional legal issues not discussed here.
I agree with Mr. Dane. Private security guards can't violate anyone's Fourth Amendment rights unless they have been formally deputized or are acting under instructions from the police. And even if they were subject to the Fourth Amendment, it sounds like this particular guard had ample justification.
Related Questions & Answers
-
I went out to Hollywood with three other girls last night. I was drinking heavily... Asked 10/23/11, 4:46 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
On what circumstances or is it legally possible for the police to enter a private... Asked 10/23/11, 5:07 am in United States California Criminal Law
-
On what circumstances or is it legally possible for the police to enter a private... Asked 10/22/11, 11:21 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
Dear lawyer, I married my wife in 2003 and we have had two children, a girl and a... Asked 10/22/11, 9:48 pm in United States California Criminal Law