Legal Question in Criminal Law in California

Need to know rights when stopped by police

The other night, I was stopped by the police when riding my bike on a rural road. They claimed someone reported me as 'hiding in the bushes and possibly the one who had been in a fight with a neighbor.' I denied the allegation and asked if there was a charge, to which they replied ''NO,'' but wouldn't let me leave till I provided ID, claiming I was ''impeding an investigation'' and that ''the 4th Amendment gave them the right to know'' or else they would arrest and jail me. What are the specific laws per being allowed to leave after being told there isn't a charge and, in this instance, if they arrested me, could I bring a false arrest suit against them? Thank you.


Asked on 10/07/03, 11:50 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Wayne Wisong Wayne Wisong, Attorney at Law

Re: Need to know rights when stopped by police

The police have a right to "briefly detain" a suspect to "investigate" if they have a "reasonable suspicion" to believe the person has committed a crime. This is a lesser standard than probable cause. They can arrest without a warrant only if they have "probable cause" to believe you committed a felony. This is defined as evidence or circumstances that would cause a reasonably skeptical police officer to believe you are probably guilty of the offense. The 4th amendment statement is kind of ludicrous...it represents your right as against the government to "due process of law". Cop crap, basically, reversing it. If they had arrested you, unless they had probable cause to believe you had committed a battery, yes, they could be subject to a false arrest suit, but the standard for civil suits against the police is somewhat lower than probable cause...it is "arguable probable cause", meaning they are immune from suit unless it was clearly a bad arrest. But lack of probable cause and the absence of a warrant would have been grounds to dismiss the charges at a preliminary hearing.

Read more
Answered on 10/08/03, 1:07 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in California