Legal Question in Criminal Law in California

Who could get into trouble with a stay-away and this situation

I have a ''stay-away'' from a woman, her 2 children (1 a minor, one is not) and her husband. The husband took it out on me because he didn't want us to see each other anymore. We were and still are in love with each other. She despite the order, still defies it (and him) by coming to me and my home. I do not turn her away but I let her in. So you know I never ever go to her. And a divorce is planned by her but until that happens she still wants to visit me. My question is ''Can I still get into trouble for violating this stay-away although it's her coming to me at her own free will''. PLEASE HELP US!

Signed....''Romeo & Juliett''....Two Lovers In Love


Asked on 4/19/01, 2:20 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Steven Mandell Law Offices of Steven R. Mandell

Re: Who could get into trouble with a stay-away and this situation

Hmmm, Romeo and Juliette... Let's see... didn't they both end up dead because of the tangled webs they (and everyone else) weaved? But enough of this. The answer to your question is "probably not" as long as everyone TOLD THE TRUTH, but you can't ever be sure. We could both probably think of a few situations where this state of affairs could result in a violation of the stay-away order and you'd be the one looking at a prosecution for violating it. Proceed at your own risk. And good luck.

Read more
Answered on 6/12/01, 12:17 am
Victor Hobbs Victor E. Hobbs

Re: Who could get into trouble with a stay-away and this situation

This reply supplements Steve M's reply.

If you are ordered to stay away from her residence then you've not violated the order. If you're ordered to stay away from her you're in technical violation of the order.

If somehow she becomes frightened (like he threatens to take away her children in the divorce) you may find that she will lie about what you did to get her to your place. And you might find yourself in some real trouble (they cost money) until it all sorts itself out.

So you're taking a risk. And certainly she is tempting the court to side with the Dad about who gets custody of the children.

Those lips that never smile are really tempting. However, you're going to live the rest of your life with the consequences of your acts. And more important so are her children.

She may be taking a real bashing at home. And she needs your emotional support. You might want to seek some sort of marriage counseling with her as strange as it may seem. So that you can reduce the damage to her children. Remember you don't know what is going on at home with Dad when she (the mom) is at your place. Loving her is not enough. You're going to have to be aware that you may be severely damaging her children. Ultimately it gets down to 'love her love her children.'

Lots of luck

Read more
Answered on 6/12/01, 2:34 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in California