Legal Question in Civil Litigation in California
Defamation of character.
My neighbors called animal services on us w/ a bogus complaint. I feel this is a defamation of my character because i take very good care of my dogs. they thought they were abandoned because we were gone & actually there was someone w/ no car at our house. so now we have to meet with an officer & in our neighborhood that is very embarassing. Can we do anything about this legally towards them?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Defamation of character.
If you have to now meet with animal control, then you can't prove that the neighbor lied.
Re: Defamation of character.
No. Reports to government agencies are generally privileged and cannot form the basis of a defamation lawsuit. Even if this call were subject to litigation, only a false statement of fact that harmed your reputation would be actionable. Reporting their belief that your animals had been left alone isn't a statement about you at all, let alone a false one. It also didn't damage your reputation since animal control has no reason to think you mistreat your pets.
Be glad you have a neighbor who cares about the welfare of animals, and try not to do anything that would make them reluctant to report any real problems that might occur in the future.