Legal Question in Investment Law in California

''Sculpture Question''

My husband is in the process of purchasing a sculpture by ***** ***** ''*Name of Sculpture*'' in silver. I have since discovered that ***** ***** (the sales rep and son of *****) has a legal checkered passed. Since my husband loves the sculpture, our question is this: How can we be certain of the actual silver content since the price is also contingent to that claim. Do we have any legal right of demanding verification of proof of silver content for this specific piece and how would one go about doing that? Can we legally request proof of silver purchases and determine the use of it in all pieces cast in ''silver''? The object is also aimed as an investment instrument. Thank you for your possible consideration of this question.


Asked on 12/15/07, 3:37 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: ''Sculpture Question''

Do you remember Archimedes and the expression ''Eureka!'' when he sat down in his bathtub and it overflowed?

As I remember this bit of history, or fable, the King had given Archimedes the job of determining the amount of gold in gifts given the King. Since they were irregular in shape, they could be weighed but not measured, and thus their volume might include a lot of base metal. Archimedes realized that his full bathtub overflowed by a volume of water exactly equal to the volume of his submerged body.

So, by weighing the sculpture, you can determine its mass, and by submerging it in a brim-full vessel of water and catching all the overflow (displaced water), you can determine the volume of the sculpture. Then it is easy to do a relatively accurate calculation of the specific gravity of the materials composing the sculpture. If it differs greatly from that of sterling, you know there's a significant amount of alloy or the silver is plated over another metal of dissimilar specific gravity.

This is not, strictly speaking, the ''Archimedes' Principle,'' which has to do with buoyancy (why steel or concrete ships float), but is a related concept (submerged articles displace water equal to their own volume, or almost).

Read more
Answered on 12/16/07, 4:21 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Investment Law questions and answers in California