Legal Question in Medical Malpractice in California

unecessary surgery

On oct 6, 1999 my wife underwent Pancreas surgery.

docoors diagnoised her as having a tumor in her pancreas.

once they did the surgery there was no tumor. They still however removed her gallbladder

because they thought that this was contributing to her abdominal pain and it looked abnormal?

I thought they should have notified me before proceeding with the gall bladder removal.

is this considered negligence/malpractice?

Thank you for your response to this matter.


Asked on 11/08/99, 5:00 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Robert E. Drescher Law Offices of Robert E. Drescher

Re: unecessary surgery

One of the primary pieces of information needed to determine if the doctors went too far is the informed consent form signed by your wife prior to the surgery. If it lists procedures ONLY related to the pancreas, then you MAY have a case. However, in my experience, the doctors tend to fill out the forms in very broad terms, thus allowing them to pretty much do what ever is necessary, in their medical opinion.

Another item to look at is the pathology report on the removed gall bladder. Was it normal??

Your matter requires a more indept look at the medical documentation prior to rendering an opinion regarding malpractice.

You should seek out an attorney who specializes in medical malpractice in your community and ask for a free consultation.

Finally, you may be prevented from filing a malpractice case and be required to file for manditory arbitration. This depens on your medical insurance carrier.

Read more
Answered on 11/12/99, 9:45 am
Joseph Marman Law Office of Joseph H. Marman

Re: unecessary surgery

You need to learn what Releases and disclosure were signed by your wife before she underwent the surgery. If it was the appropriate thing to do and there was no option for the doctor to do but to remove the gall bladder, there would be no negligence. What were the down sides of removing the gall bladder, and what were the upsides? How easy would it have been for the doctors to discuss the surgery with you before removing the gall bladder? Would a delay have cause a risk to your wife. You must discuss with another doctor what the appropriate standard of care would have been of the doctors performing the surgery.

Read more
Answered on 11/11/99, 8:19 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Medical Malpractice Law questions and answers in California