Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California
Buying out an ex-spouse
I was divorced in 2002 and the appraisal of our joint owned property was $297,000. Our divorce was final in 2002 and I made all the payments, prop taxes and assoc. fees for the past 4 years tho we remained co-owners. He wants me to ''buy him out'' now and wants half of todays current market value which it is appraised at about $600,000. Is this fair? or can/should I deduct the amounts of mortgage payments I've made during these past 4 years...which totals $70,000. I did use the interest at tax time as a write off...does that have an effect? What does the law say about this?
3 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Buying out an ex-spouse
You were entitled to the write-off on the taxes, but if you were living in the house, whether or not to deduct the entire mortgage may depend upon the fair rental value. Call me directly at 6192223504.
Re: Buying out an ex-spouse
If you are equal co-owners as tenants in common or joint tenants, and each contributed equally to the down-payment, each is entitled to 1/2 of the net equity upon sale, except as modified by the divorce decree or any other contract between you; however, you are entitled to reimbursement for your excess contributions (above 1/2) to necessary costs of ownership such as mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance and necessary repairs and maintenance. As for voluntary repairs, maintenance and improvements, reimbursement of an excess money contribution would depend upon a prior agreement that the improvement would be made.
The ex-spouse in possession does not owe rent to the out-of-possession co-owner.
Tax deductions for mortgage interest are supposed to be taken by the person who was obligated to make the payment, and actually did make the payment. It's been a long time since I researched the issue of what happens if one spouse pays all the interest and takes all the deduction, but I think if the obligation on the note is joint and several (as usual), you can take the entire deduction if you paid the full amount. Check this with a tax specialist.
Re: Buying out an ex-spouse
Mr. Whipple is right on as a general statement of the law, but it really depends on the language of your divorce decree.