Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California
can the city we live in fine us for have junk in our back yard? Even if our neighbor complained about it? The only way you can see it is if you go back into our yard? Isn't that considered violating our privacy?
2 Answers from Attorneys
If you dispute it, there may be an administrative process. it is not the issue of privacy, but that it may not meet the definition of a blight - if that is what you were sited with. A blight, by common sense, should be something you can see not just when you are on your own property.
Best,
Daniel Bakondi, Esq.
The Law Office of Daniel Bakondi
870 Market Street, Suite 1161
San Francisco CA 94102
415-450-0424
IMPORTANT NOTICE: This communication may contain confidential information, privileged information, or attorney work product. If you are not the intended recipient or received this message in error, any use or distribution of this message is strictly prohibited and unlawful. Please notify the sender immediately, and delete this message. No attorney-client nor confidential relationship is created through this communication. Nothing communicated or provided constitutes legal advice nor a legal opinion unless it so specifies and written agreement for attorney services has been entered into. Your issue may be time sensitive and may result in loss of rights if you do not act in time. Thank you.
I haven't read the ordinance, but my guess is that the answer is yes.
As to the privacy issue, your neighbor does not appear to have committed a privacy violation by noticing a violation of the law. Think of it this way.......if you saw your neighbor, acress the same fence, beating his wife, and reported it to the police, would invasion of privacy be a valid defense? Of course not.
There is a "plain sight rule" in criminal law that distinguishes evidence can be observed without a search from evidence that, if discovered, might have been discovered as the result of an unreasonable search under the 4th Amendment and thus required the owner's consent or a search warrant. What a neighbor can see over or through the boundary fence is clearly in plain sight and not subject to a violation of privacy defense.