Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California
Closing Early House Not Complete w/No Delivery Date
Reserved a new developement home in So Cal in Feb, went to contract in July, was told by developer house to be delivered by Oct 2004. Lock in rate expires Dec 3rd and house still not complete along with 10 other houses on street. No committment of delivery date. We close next week, can I negotiate a discount with developer for an incentive based on our funding 100% of the loan and he is not committing to delivery? I feel he is control, if I dont like it I can walk, and he can sell to someone else.
If I complain can he refuse to sell to me this late in the contract?? Where is the fairness?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: Closing Early House Not Complete w/No Delivery Date
The right answer here will be heavily dependent upon what's written in your contracts. The developer's oral statements about completion date are probably legally ineffective.
Your contract will also contain the answers as to the rights, if any, of either the developer or you to terminate the contract for one reason or another, including construction delays or failure to obtain financing on acceptable terms.
You can, of course, attempt to negotiate contract modifications such as a discount for your assuming a greater financing burden such as paying all cash, but unless you have some leverage due to the developer being in breach of some duty under the written contract, the developer is unlikely to make concessions.
What do the other buyers have to say? Maybe the eleven of you should get together to discuss a common strategy.
The developer probably can't walk away from the deal based only on your suggesting changes to your contract, so long as you remain apparently ready, willing and able to perform your obligations under the contract. On the other hand, if the developer is in "material" breach of its agreement with you, perhaps you can back out. You should retain a lawyer if you decide to do this.
Basically, what it boils down to is that the enforceable parts of your agreements and understandings will be in your contract, including what constitutes a breach and what remedies are available for breach. Once these are found and studied, you can apply general principles of contract and real property law and figure out a practical solution.