Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

Dog (Pet) in Violation of Lease

We live in an Irvine Apartment complex and two months ago, a tenant moved in with a 100+ pound German Shepard. The leases in the complex limit pet weight to 40 pounds, and management has contacted the tenants, advising them they either have to vacate, or find an alternate solution for the dog. They refuse to do either. It is now in ''legal'' (translation, nothing will be done). And to compound the matter, they refuse to clean up their dog's waste, and sections of the development are now their personal litter box. The other tenants and I all have small (most under 20 pounds) dogs. What recourse to the other upset tenants and I have in this matter, if any?


Asked on 4/22/03, 4:41 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

Jason Hsu Una Law Corporation

Re: Dog (Pet) in Violation of Lease

You option is to await for your landlord to complete the "legal" action. It is your landlord who must evict the tenants for violation of the lease. You may have available remedies for yourself if the dog is causing so much disturbance that it is affecting your quiet enjoyment of the premises.

The information provided to you is of a general nature. We hope this information has been helpful to you, but you should always obtain competent legal counsel who is familiar with your specific legal issues to determine the best course of action. If we can help you in the future with anything, please feel free to email or contact us at www.unalaw.com

Read more
Answered on 4/22/03, 4:59 pm
Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Dog (Pet) in Violation of Lease

I agree with the previous response. A lease is a contract between the landlord and the tenant, not a compact between tenants. It is possible that a court would find that other tenants (such as yourself) are intended third-party beneficiaries of the dog-weight limitation in the offending co-tenant's lease, but asserting that theory in court would be time-consuming and expensive in comparison with the landlord's quick and cheap eviction-through-unlawful detainer remedy, and not recommended.

Read more
Answered on 4/22/03, 5:09 pm
H.M. Torrey The Law Offices of H.M. Torrey

Re: Dog (Pet) in Violation of Lease

you may have legal remedies available to you as an intended third party beneficiary in which the clause in the lease was "directly" for the benefit of the other tenants, in which you are on. you could assert specific performance of this lease term as a third party beneficiary or you could sue under a tortious theory known as "nuisance" if the dog is detrimentally affecting your quiet use and enjoyment of your premises as a tenant. thus, if you do not want to necessarily wait on your landlord's unlawful detainer remedies, these would be your strongest causes of action available to you and the other tenants affected by this "oversized" dog. if you would like additional legal assistance in this matter, feel free to email my office today with more details. at any rate, we wish you the best and hope you get justice in this matter asap.

Read more
Answered on 4/22/03, 7:00 pm
Lyle Johnson Bedi and Johnson Attorneys at Law

Re: Dog (Pet) in Violation of Lease

Call animal control, the health department, and code enforcement and report, as you describe it, the large quantity of fecal matter on the ground. Keep calling until you find someone who will take action. Leaving the fecal matter on the ground creates a health hazard. Either the tenant or the landlord will have to clean it up. Either way the dog will probably go.

Read more
Answered on 4/22/03, 10:22 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California