Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

Does an easement exist and can it be rerouted?

A 5 acre parcel I am interested in has a gravel access road through the middle. No written easement is listed in the last deed -- though the title search has not yet been done.

This road is used by the owner of the vacant parcel nextdoor, whenever they visit their lot. They have also maintained the road, they say.

It has probably been over five years they have used it. And they sound as if they were on a friendly basis toward previous owners.

If no written easement is found, do they have a prescriptive easement? Or possibly a previous owner gave them permission -- wouldn't that preclude a prescriptive easement? But what if no record of an agreement is found giving them permission?

If this does qualify as an easement, can I reroute it without their permission? And can it be rerouted from a different direction and to a different point in their property? Thank you!


Asked on 10/22/03, 6:58 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

Ken Koenen Koenen & Tokunaga, P.C.

Re: Does an easement exist and can it be rerouted?

You are puting the cart before the horse. First, get the prelim and see what it says.

Next, talk to the seller of the property and ask him about the situation.

Finally, call the neighbor and discuss the matter in a non-threatening manner (you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar).

If all else fails, whether there is a prescriptive easement or not will depend on all of the facts, which can not be ascertained by your question here.

Read more
Answered on 10/23/03, 2:50 pm
Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Does an easement exist and can it be rerouted?

It would not be unusual for the deed to the servient, or burdened parcel (the one you're thinking of buying) to make no reference to an easement across it. Among other reasons, the easement could have been created at a later date. Also, the easement may have arisen from one of several causes other than express (written) grant, dedication or reservation, such as prescription, necessity or implication.

Easements by prescription arise from adverse use over a five-year period. Easements by necessity or so-called implied easements result from an earlier subdivision where an otherwise-landlocked parcel would have been created but for the easement the law implies.

These concepts of easement creation have many technical nuances and only an attorney with a fair amount of experience in the area can competently advise with respect to the existence of these usually-unwritten, unrecorded easements.

Under the circumstances you describe, I think it is rather likely there is some kind of easement, although as one of the attorneys mentioned, the use of the road across this lot MIGHT upon close examination of the facts turn out to be nothing more than a license, which is probably revocable, although not always, because there are isolated examples of licenses ripening into easements by estoppel through the carelessness or indifference of the grantor of the license.

The general rule about relocating easements is that once its location is fixed or established by use neither the servient parcel owner nor the easement holder may unilaterally relocate the easement. An exception is when the grant or easement gives an express right to relocate. It is also remotely possible that a court might order relocation of an easement under hardship circumstances, but I find no California case where this happened.

Read more
Answered on 10/24/03, 7:04 pm
Michael Olden Law Offices of Michael A. Olden

Re: Does an easement exist and can it be rerouted?

All way too complicated a set of issues without more detail. The more to the point why, why all of these questions and why you want to reroute the road. If this is raw land, is it raw land as to the neighbor also would do they have improvements upon the property. Why don't you just ask them to say if they would mind if the road were rerouted so that it met their property at a different point. If you wish to consult with the I have numerous other questions before I could advise you. I'm in the San Francisco Bay Area at 925 -- 945 -- 6000

Read more
Answered on 10/22/03, 7:30 pm
Donald Holben Donald R. Holben & Associates, APC

Re: Does an easement exist and can it be rerouted?

Why not ask the owners information re these rights. If permission given, ie., they have a license, that license can be withdrawn, however if open and notorious use, they likely have a prescriptive right Try to work with your eighbor. They may sue for an easement if denied. They would have to state in their suit what their theories are. Try to avoid this. Seller should disclose such info to you upon sale.

Read more
Answered on 10/23/03, 1:01 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California