Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California
Escrow rules
We were told Escrow would close on Dec. 6 (It was a 60 day Escrow). It is now Dec. 16 and because the person who is buying our old house (buying our new house is contingent on the buyer buying our old house) has had problems with his loan papers, we are stuck in our old house with nothing! Everything is in storage and we are paying extra fees. Can we be compensated at all?
Thank you
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Escrow rules
That depends entirely on the terms of your contract with the buyers of your old house.
Re: Escrow rules
It's not a matter of 'escrow rules,' it's a basic matter of breach of contract and remedies for breach. If your contract with your buyer called for performance (i.e., closing) by a certain date, and because of their fault this has not happened, the contract has been breached; if you have suffered foreseeable harm as a result of the breach, you may be entitled to damages.
Having said that, let me qualify my answer as follows. First, whether there is such a breach as to warrant damages depends upon the language of the contract. Generally, it must (and probably does) have a time-is-of-the-essence clause. Second, your lawyer would need to review the language for anything that might give the buyers a legally-satisfactory reason to delay closing, such as some contingency that they could assert as not satisfied. Third, the real estate and escrow/title businesses seem to have a code of their own, based on decades of trade custom and practice, sometimes local in nature, that may determine under what circumstances and length of delay a seller can obtain damages, and in what amount. Therefore, you may want to make local inquiry, including asking your real-estate broker and perhaps your title officer. Their answers might be tainted by desire to get the deal done, so if they don't ring true, get a free consultation with a local real-estate attorney.
Whether your remedy should be pursued in court or through arbitration may depend upon whether the parties opted to have disputes arbitrated. This is a 'check the boxes' section on many real-estate purchase agreements.
Finally, before initiating any demand or suit, think about whether this might cause the buyers to back out entirely, making a small problem much bigger. You might want to postpone asking for damages until after your deal closes (if it does).