Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

Note on a house

I currently hold a note on a property for sale in San Francisco. I am the first lien holder and when it sells I project to be paid out. Also, I have a judgment against the person who owned the house, but lost it to the bank in foreclosure. I signed off my judgement to a collections company to go after the judgement owed to me. The collections Co. gets 30% of anything collected off the judgment. Question is: Is the collections company entitled to collect money off the sale of the house that I have a note on? The house is no longer in possession of the debtor, it now belongs to the bank. The collections Co. is to go after the judgment, not the proceeds from the sale of the house the debtor once owned?


Asked on 5/16/09, 8:13 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Note on a house

Sir, I'm sorry to say that your question reflects a fair amount of misuderstanding about the business of secured lending, collections and the enforcement of judgments. I'd suggest that if you are doing a significant amount of real-estate lending to strangers, that you either ally yourself with an experienced and reputable hard-money lender or get a local lawyer to coach you.

First, I don't know how it is possible to lose a judgment in a foreclosure. A money judgment should be placed on the public record by recording an abstract of judgment in each county where the judgment debtor may have property. Then, there are multiple paths to enforcement, including foreclosure on real property, garnishment of wages, and on and on. So, you can't lose your judgment, really; what may have happened is that the "bank" had a lien that was senior to your judgment in time of recording as to one asset - but your judgment is still there; it simply fell into second position behind a senior secured creditor as to that particular property.

Your relationship with a collections company with respect to your judgment is governed by the law of contracts. Basically, this means that your rights to proceeds from collection efforts of the judgment are determined by the deal you made with the bill collector. The bill collector is entitled to whatever your contract with them says, not more, not less.

Read more
Answered on 5/17/09, 2:04 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California