Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

Real Estate Deposit in Dispute

I was recently sued for specific performance to sign escrow cancellation instructions where the buyer didn't perform. Litigation ensued two years ago, resulting in a settlement where I paid the buyer $108,000 for work they had done on my home during escrow. They also received $60,000 from the broker. I was not able to refinance my home in time for the agreed-upon settlement date; the amount went to judgment. I subsequently paid the $108,000 (approximately 2 months later), and also was ordered to pay their attorney's fees, which was not part of the settlement. Their attorney argued that because it went to judgment that they became the prevailing party which kicked in the atty's fees provision of the contract of sale. I had such poor representation that I am looking for someone to help me in a suit against my former lawyer. There was quite a bit of malpractice on his part, including settling with the brokers for nothing, which I did not authorize! He did this because he was about to be sanctioned (again) for not answering discovery. At any rate, right now I have to answer the complaint by tomorrow. Can I serve it by mail? Do I have to file by tomorrow or just serve it?

Thanks!!


Asked on 7/28/03, 10:11 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

H.M. Torrey The Law Offices of H.M. Torrey

Re: Real Estate Deposit in Dispute

from the facts given so far, it does appear time is very much of the essence here. however, unless i am not following you correctly here, how will you be serving your response without having filled it out yet, based on your final question in your submission? if you would like to clarify your case for me, please email me directly with your contact phone number, and we can call you first thing in the morning to help assist you legally in this matter if at all possible. we can certainly help you on the malpractice issue as well once we get more detailed information.

Read more
Answered on 7/28/03, 10:59 pm
Dieter Zacher Law Offices of Dieter Zacher

Re: Real Estate Deposit in Dispute

You must serve the Answer by either personal service or mail. Make sure you provide a proof of service. Otherwise, the clerk will not accept the filing of your Answer. Further, the Answer must be filed with the clerk of the court within 30 days of service. If you fail to do so, the plaintiff can take your default essentially kicking you out of court. The best service is personal service. You can deliver it to the attorney's office yourself. Or, you can fax and mail it. Again, make sure you prepare a proof of service indicating the date service was made, where and upon whom and attach a copy to the Answer when you file it with the court.

Read more
Answered on 7/29/03, 12:27 am
Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Real Estate Deposit in Dispute

Your most critical date is the filing date, but you won't be permitted to file unless your answer has, appended to it, a 'proof of service' showing that service on the plaintiff has been initiated.........however, the service on the plaintiff may consist merely of mailing a copy of your Answer to the plaintiff's attorney. The actual delivery need not be accomplished until the USPS gets around to it.

Although I don't recommend filing an Answer late, the thing to remember is that your Answer is not disregarded unless you not only miss the 30-day cutoff, but also the plaintiff files a request for entry of default. Thus, you can sometimes get away with filing an Answer 31 or more days after being served. My point is not that it's OK to delay; rather, that just because you missed the deadline you shouldn't concede defeat -- get your damn Answer in late if necessary, but ASAP.

If, somehow, the plaintiff manages to take your default, you can petition fore relief from default. You should not be representing yourself if this is necessary.

The Answer should be on "pleading paper" (numbered lines, vertical marginal rules) and meet California Rules of Court requirements for a pleading; i.e. proper caption and, if the Complaint is verified, the Answer must also be verified. An Answer should admit or deny each material allegation of the Complaint and set up at least one defense against each cause of action. Usually, lawyer-prepared Answers have denials and afirmative defenses, most of which are quite technical.

Read more
Answered on 7/29/03, 1:30 am
Larry Rothman Larry Rothman & Associates

Re: Real Estate Deposit in Dispute

We can help you answer the complaint by tomorrow and you can serve an answer by mail. You may have a right for a cross-complaint for malpractice. Please contact our office for an immediate consultation.

Read more
Answered on 7/29/03, 10:14 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California