Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

Real Estate-Notice of Default

In August 2002, I entered into a six-month lease for a townhouse from a private ownwer; however, I've just became aware that there has been a Notice Of Default filed with the county recorders office.

I want to know my rights as a tenant. Under a Notice of Default, it is my understanding that there is a ''Cure Period'' meaning the owner has the opportunity to make up the delinquent house payments. If not cured, this will result in foreclosure.

My question is: Do I as a tenant have the right to withold my rent as of result of this situation?

Secondly, would I have any legal recourse against the owner if this person knowingly accepted my move-in fees and was already delinquent on their mortgage. Given that delinquency will inevitably result in foreclosure of the property if not cured.


Asked on 10/28/02, 4:16 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Real Estate-Notice of Default

There is a practice called 'rent skimming' which involves pocketing rent, tenant deposits, etc. while letting the property slide into foreclosure. If done in the first year of ownership, the practice is forbidden by the Civil Code, see sections 890 through 894. See 890(a) for definitions and 891(d) for tenant's remedies. It does not appear that withholding rent is an authorized remedy, so I would avoid that.

The rights of a tenant in a foreclosure depend upon whether the lease is senior to the lien being foreclosed. If your lease predates the lien, the party foreclosing said lien must respect your lease provided he/she had actual or constructive notice of the lease. A lender often is charged with constructive notice of a lease if the owner lives elsewhere or if the property is clearly income property, such as an apartment building.

If you have only a six-month lease from August, and the Notice of Default is recent, your lease may expire near, or perhaps before, the foreclosure sale takes place (if it does), so this may not be much of a concern.

Many foreclosing lenders would not mind having a good tenant in the property during and shortly after a foreclosure, as this assures the property will be somewhat cared for.

Until the foreclosure is consummated, your rights as a tenant are essentially unaffected, except that the landlord may be in breach of his covenants of possession and quiet enjoyment at such time as your rights under the lease are threatened, at which point you would acquire additional rights for damages for the breach. Until the problems worsen beyond a Notice of Default, I don't think the landlord is in breach or that you (yet) have any special rights.

Read more
Answered on 10/28/02, 5:24 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California