Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California
Short sale complete, 2nd bank now wants payment
We purchased a house CA as our
primary residence. In early 2007 we
refinanced - a 1st and 2nd to
710k. Lowered our monthly
payment, raised loan value about
15k, and we used the $ to remodel a
bathroom.
In late 2007, our jobs were hit by
the mortgage crisis, we entered
into a short sale with the lenders
through our realtor
Our realtor was in contact with the
banks, told us the short sale
would relieve us of our debt. house
sold as a short sale in July,
2008.
Now the second lender is telling us
we owe the full value of the 2nd
($100,000) as ''unsecured debt.'' I
contacted our realtor, who told us
''they said they weren't going to do
that'' and then emailed us a form
from the bank which they evidently
had before the short sale finalized,
stating that we would be on the hook
for the remainder of the balance.
We never saw the form, it was not
included in the sale documents. We
did not sign this form, however, our
realtor apparently had gotten it,
and sent it to us a week ago.
It appears our options are to A)
negotiate with the second bank to
come to a settlement amount, B) get
a RE attorney to get the realtor into
court and hash it out, or C)
bankruptcy
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: Short sale complete, 2nd bank now wants payment
You are spot on correct about your options. If you choose option B you could sue the realtor for practicing law without a license, although there is some neglect on your part because you did not consult a lawyer before agreeing to the terms of a short sale. You could also choose both option B and option C. If you were to file bankruptcy, the trustee probably would have no interest in your lawsuit against your realtor and abandon the claim. So you may be able to get a discharge of the debt and still collect money from the realtor.