Legal Question in Real Estate Law in California

Water Damage and Shoddy Maintenance for 5+ Years

A portion of the ceiling in our bathroom collapsed and fell into our tub. The decaying condition of the ceiling has been visible to the eye for several years (mold, cracks, even water leaking through the bathroom light socket). Management has been informed many times about the condition, but only shoddy ''band-aid'' repairs have been made. Our upstairs neighbor has the shower going sometimes 4 hours a day, which is really his own business; IMO it is the shoddy repairs that have resulted in a portion of the ceiling now laying in our bathtub. The mold and cracked ceiling has spread to another bathroom area, and pictures have been taken. We have not contacted anyone legally yet, but want to know what our rights are, and next steps to take. Since there is plaster and exposed insulation hanging down, would also like to know if we can use other facilities until this is repaired, and at whose cost? Thanks in advance.


Asked on 5/28/02, 8:08 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Victor Hobbs Victor E. Hobbs

Re: Water Damage and Shoddy Maintenance for 5+ Years

You're probably on a month to month tenancy. Which means when you complain they'll give you a 30 day notice to move. Which is retaliatory. However, who'll win in court is up for grabs. So that leaves you Civil Code Section 1942 remedies. You may notice the landlord concerning repairs that are necessary. And if the landlord doesn't respond you may have the work done, and take it out of one months rent. You can only go up to one months rent, and do this once each twelve month period. Sounds like the repairs probably exceed one months rent. That leaves you to withhold rent until the landlord does the repairs. Again the judge at the ensuing trial will be the final determinator of who is in the right or wrong. And judges tend to realize that landlords need to have you out to do major repairs. So the judge is very likely to reduce the rent you'll owe. But award the landlord possession. This means you'll have to move. And the Unlawful Detainer Complaint will be held against you by any landlord that subscribes to a U. D. Service contemplating you as a tenant. You should consider moving as an alternative to legal action. The mold is your real problem. How's that effecting your health? At this time I'm not aware of any authority (medical or otherwise) that really knows the possible adverse health consequences.

Read more
Answered on 5/28/02, 2:05 pm
Lyle Johnson Bedi and Johnson Attorneys at Law

Re: Water Damage and Shoddy Maintenance for 5+ Years

An alternative course of action would be to contact the local building department regarding the condition of the bathroom city. The building inspector can order the apartment owner to make the necessary repairs. The citation from the building department will be helpful if the apartment ownere takes legal action. This action will also give you some ammunition to show retaliatory eviction.

Read more
Answered on 5/29/02, 2:19 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in California