Legal Question in Business Law in Delaware

Can a seller back out of a purchase?

A seller places an advertisement for a rare antique that the seller erroneously understood and advertised as one type, but that the buyer recognized as a more valuable type. Does the buyer have any legal obligation to inform the seller that the antique is more valuable that the seller thinks it is?

Once the seller has received payment and the buyer has taken posession of the merchandise, does the seller have any legal recourse to reverse the transaction?

The item was purchased by a buyer in California from a seller in Delaware.

Thank you for any information.


Asked on 9/20/02, 1:09 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Can a seller back out of a purchase?

The law of mistake in the formation of contracts is quite complex and confusing, if not confused. Basically, you have here a unilateral mistake, i.e. the seller was unaware of the true nature of the item sold, but the buyer was aware. A leading authority (Restatement of Contracts, sections 153 and 154) would give the innocent and mistaken seller the right to rescind provided he did not assume the risk of mistake, either expressly or by implication. A court might hold that the seller, who was a dealer with supposedly superior knowledge, assumed the risk. However, the bottom line is that this matter could go either way at trial, with the judge trying to do 'the right thing' and applying the portion of case law that supports his feelings of what's right and ignoring the rest.

I believe there is a tendency in modern times to hold that the seller assumes the risk that he has failed to understand the true market value of an item he deals in and inadvertently underprices.

If, however, the buyer participated in or encouraged the seller's mistake, the court would be much more inclined to allow rescission.

This answer is based on general U.S. law and is not specific to Delaware.

Read more
Answered on 9/20/02, 2:10 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Business Law questions and answers in Delaware