Legal Question in Constitutional Law in District of Columbia
Is not SCOTUS in Elk ...v. Newdow suborning acts against the establishment and
Did SCOTUS (in Elk � v. Newdow) create a right - among the superior rights of a �primary� custodial (�final say�) parent - i.e., within that parent�s (separate and unequal) �private parent-child sphere� - to allow third parties to instruct the custodial parent�s child in that third parties� (and the custodial parent�s) beliefs while the third parties is simultaneously involved in illegal activity � so long as the illegal activity is suborn by the State � thereby (SCOTUS itself) suborning acts against establishment and equal protection clauses?
Suppose a Sheriff instructed Benning�s child in Judeo-Christian �God� beliefs of George Washington etc, while said Sheriff stood atop the necks of a negro and Jew? If said negro and Jew died or were comatose as result of Sheriff�s activities and the local community and State suborned the activity, wouldn�t SCOTUS also have to defer to Benning�s Court Order granting her �final say� rights over any disagreement Newdow might have with Benning�s endorsement of the Sheriff�s religious instructions under such circumstances except that SCOTUS would �recognize� (�heckler�/no standing) Newdow�s right to instruct his daughter in Newdow�s Atheist beliefs were not disparaged?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: Is not SCOTUS in Elk ...v. Newdow suborning acts against the establishment
In the recent Newdow decision, the U.S. Supreme Court merely opined that plaintiff Newdow was without the proper standing to bring the lawsuit in the first place since he did not have primary(physical) custody of his daughter at the time the case was filed.
Nothing more is implicated in this decision nor is
there anything in my opinion to support the line of gibberish which you've offered in your ill-formed question.
Related Questions & Answers
-
Recall Can the President of the United States be recalled? Asked 10/08/03, 2:18 pm in United States District of Columbia Constitutional Law
Looking for something else?
10,200 active attorneys ready to answer your legal questions today.
Featured Attorneys
Earn additional revenue and grow your business.
