Legal Question in Criminal Law in Florida

Misdemeanour -1 petty theft

A few months ago I was arrested for shoplifting in Florida, I reside in VA. My lawyer in Florida told me there it wasn't necessary to travel to and fro for the hearings as it would make no difference to my case. The prosecutors, it seems, have refused to drop the case, but my lawyer said that I got the next best thing -They are willing to let me do community service for 6 months(in VA)and stay out of trouble,after which they will dissmiss the case.

Should I take this offer? Is this the same as diversion?

My lawyer says this is NOT a sentence and I have NOT been convicted, so I may expunge my arrest later and I may truthfully claim to no convictions in future. Will that mean I have a clean record thereafter?

What exactly does community service mean? what might they ask me to do? Is it the same as volunteering? I am currently already volunteering in the County library and animal shelter, can this be called community service?

I appreciate your advise in this matter. Thankyou!


Asked on 11/04/04, 11:09 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Valerie Masters Valerie Masters, P.A.

Re: Misdemeanour -1 petty theft

THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTION. FIRST, YOUR LAWYER SHOULD BE ANSWERING THESE QUESTIONS FOR YOU AND IF HE/SHE ISN'T YOU SHOULD DEMAND TO BE INFORMED. THATS A LAWYERS JOB. IF HOWEVER, YOU ARE JUST GETTING A SECOND OPINION, THIS IS WHAT I CAN TELL FROM THE FACTS YOU HAVE PRESENTED.YOU ARE VERY LUCKY NOT TO BE PRESENT IN COURT, AND LUCKY NOT TO BE FACING A CONVICTION OF ANY KIND. TECHNICALLY YOU COULD CALL THIS A "DIVERSION" PROGRAM BECAUSE YOU ARE BEING "DIVERTED" FROM THE NORMAL COURSE OF A CASE. FORMAL DIVERSION PROGRAMS IN MY COUNTY ARE CALLED "PRETRIAL INTERVENTION", "DEFERRED PROSECUTION", "PADD". IT SOUNDS YOU ARE EVEN IN A LESS FORMAL ARRANGEMENT THAN THAT. HOWEVER, A SENTENECE TO COMMUNITY SERVICE IS NOT USUALLY FOR A PERIOD OF TIME, ITS A NUMBER OF HOURS, IE. 100 HOURS. SO MAYBE YOU ARE IN A "DEFFERED PROSECUTION AGREEMENT" FOR 6 MONTHS, DO COMMUNITY SERVICE, PICK UP NO NEW CHARGES, AND THEN GET THE CASE DROPPED. ITS HARD TO TELL FROM YOUR FACTS IN THE QUESTION. YES, YOU CAN SEAL OR EXPUNGE AN ARREST IF A CASE IS NOLLE PROSSED OR RECEIVE A WITHHOLD OF ADJUDICATION. YOU SHOULD KNOW THAT YOU HAVE ONE CHANCE IN A LIFETIME IN FLORIDA TO SEAL OR EXPUNGE AN ARREST SO CHOSE YOUR CHANCE WISELY. DEPENDING ON YOUR AGE, OCCUPATION, AND CRIMINAL RECORD YOU MIGHT WANT TO SAVE THIS CHANCE FOR SOMETHING MORE SERIOUS THAN A DROPPED PETITE THEFT. IF YOUR CASE IS NOLLE PROSSED OR RECEIVE A WITTHOLD OF ADJUDICATION YOU CAN SAY YOU HAVE NO CONVICTION. IF YOUR CASE IS SEALED OR EXPUNGE I BELIEVE YOU NEED NEVER ADMIT THE ARREST. ANY NON PROFIT ORGANIZATION IS USUALLY ACCEPTABLE UNLESS YOU NEED TO GET APPROVAL FROM THE FLORIDA COMMUNITY SERVICE PROGRAM. OVERALL, THE DEAL LOOKS GOOD TO ME. AGAIN, IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU NEED A SHORT CONVERSATION WITH YOUR ATTORNEY. IF YOU ARE UNHAPPY WITH COUNSEL CONSIDER HIRING PRIVATE COUNSEL TO EXPLAIN THESE ISSUES AND TO LATER SEAL YOUR ARREST. I HAVE BEEN PRACTICING CRIMINAL LAW IN FLORIDA FOR 8 YEARS AND KNOW JUST ABOUT EVERY PROSECUTOR AND DEFENSE ATTORNEY IN PALM BEACH. LET ME KNOW IF I CAN BE OF FURTHER ASSISTANCE, VALERIE MASTERS (561) 659-9410.

Read more
Answered on 11/05/04, 1:25 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in Florida