Legal Question in Criminal Law in Florida

My wife was arrested last year for assault and battery. When she went to court they dropped the assault case and adjudication was with held on the battery. We were told that because of this nothing would show up on her criminal history. Yet, a couple of weeks ago we went to get an apartment and were denied because of her criminal history. Why did it show up? Now we have had 5 other apartments between these times why didn't it show up then? Is it on her record or not? Can an employer see it? When asked has she been convicted or deferred adjudication what does she put? Is deferred the same as with held?


Asked on 12/09/09, 4:34 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Brian Leifert Leifert & Leifert

A withholding of adjudication is not a conviction. The disposition will remain on your wife's record but without a formal conviction. It the case was handled under the domestic violence battery statutes, she will be unable to seal the record. Read the following links for more information:

http://www.leifertlaw.com/lawyer-attorney-1169492.html

http://www.leifertlaw.com/lawyer-attorney-1169499.html

Read more
Answered on 12/14/09, 5:51 am
Brent Rose The Orsini & Rose Law Firm

In the old days, when you weren't sent to jail, the judge "withheld adjudication." Job applications were supposed to say, "Have you ever been convicted?" (That's how the statute reads.) If you hadn't been to jail, which is all anyone apparently cared about, you could say "no." These days, job applications ask things like, "Have you ever been arrested, convicted, had adjudication withheld, etc.," and the answer has to be "yes." She should look into having her record sealed, in which case she could lawfully deny the arrest, the withholding of adjudication, and everything else on apartment applications and almost all job applications. However, as Mr. Leifert has suggested, based on how you described the charged, she may not qualify to have the record sealed.

Read more
Answered on 12/14/09, 7:31 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in Florida