Legal Question in Family Law in Florida

Fed Ct. Case-Can a Party to a Case Be Supoena'd?

This is a family law case re: the care of my aged mother. She's in a nursing home, but we'd like to supoena her to court so she could refute the charges and allegations that have been brought against our family regarding her care--and also substantiate truths regarding her wishes and plans. Can we compel the nursing home to release her to court--because it behooves them to keep her out of the proceedings--and I'm sure they'll say she's too frail to come--and probably make it seem like we don't care about her and asking her to court is just another example of that...

If we can get her to come, do we do so via motion or an order to compel or supoena? This is in Federal court... Also, if we can't get her to come via some sort of legal motion, can we bring a notary and have an oral/written deposition interrogatory performed in the nursing home? (They don't allow us any privacy w/our mom--we'd probably have to do it in the hall/in front of nursing staff!)


Asked on 4/28/08, 3:14 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Brent Rose The Orsini & Rose Law Firm

Re: Fed Ct. Case-Can a Party to a Case Be Supoena'd?

Are you sure it's in Federal Court? Federal court does not have a family law division.

At any rate, whether your case is in state or Federal court, yes, you are entitled to have a subpoena issued by the clerk (or by your attorney, if you have one), that compels your mother to come to court. However, that doesn't mean that the nursing home has to bring her to court. If your mother is unable to come to court, it's your responsibility to get her there. The nursing home may file a motion to quash (nullify) your subpoena based on her health, but you'll have to take that up in front of the judge. You might even have to bring a doctor with you to say she's healthy enough to come to court.

If your mother isn't healthy enough to come to court, you can take a deposition to perpetuate her testimony, which will allow you to take her testimony at the nursing home before a court reporter and read her transcript in court (or let the judge read it).

But I have to warn you: if you don't have one, get a lawyer. You are dealing with some very technical rules of procedure here that even many lawyers don't understand. Judges--particularly Federal judges--can impose harsh sanctions for the slightest misstep when it comes to these rules. You don't want to do this on your own. I always say, there's nothing more expensive than NOT having a lawyer.

Read more
Answered on 4/28/08, 3:46 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Family Law, Divorce, Child Custody and Adoption questions and answers in Florida