Legal Question in Civil Litigation in Florida

How do I halt a mechanic's lien on a vehicle? My son-in law took his car into a repair shop to see what was wrong with his transmission. The shop advertised a free diagnosis and my son-in law asked just to make sure first. They initially told him it would cost around around $800 to repair, at first sight but said they needed to pull out the transmission for a better look.......... he then asked would the diagnosis work still be free and they said yes. After that they looked at the car and said it would cost about $1900 to fix, he then told them he couldn't afford that not to do any work on it and he'd pick it up. He was prepared to pay the $800 but not $1900. The shop told him okay but he had to first pay for taking out the transmission..........which would be about $400.

He explained that they advertised a free diagnosis and that he asked them about that prior to them looking at it. He would have even paid to have it looked at if it had been a reasonable amount. He called them again and they claimed that they had started to work on it so now he would have to pay the $1900. My son-in law has tried everything he contacted Consumer affairs, the BBB, but the shop submitted falsified paperwork. They copied and pasted his signature on a false estimate that even contradicts them, using his signature written for the free diagnosis. Which he can prove is false once he gets to court. He has gone to the police who can not help........ and he doesn't have the $1900. He filed a small claims suit which he hasn't got a date for yet. In the meanwhile they filed for a mechanics lien and the time is almost up the car goes to auction in a week. We've looked at review sites for this business and see that there are similar complaints made about them but that doesn't help us now.


Asked on 12/15/10, 7:41 am

1 Answer from Attorneys

Angelo Marino Angelo Marino Jr. PA

See a consumer lawyer in your area and look at

559.905 Written motor vehicle repair estimate and disclosure statement required.--

1. (1) When any customer requests a motor vehicle repair shop to perform repair work on a motor vehicle, the cost of which repair work will exceed $100 to the customer, the shop shall prepare a written repair estimate, which is a form setting forth the estimated cost of repair work, including diagnostic work, before effecting any diagnostic work or repair. The written repair estimate shall also include the following items:

(a) The name, address, and telephone number of the motor vehicle repair shop.

(b) The name, address, and telephone number of the customer.

(c) The date and time of the written repair estimate.

(d) The year, make, model, odometer reading, and license tag number of the motor vehicle.

(e) The proposed work completion date.

(f) A general description of the customer's problem or request for repair work or service relating to the motor vehicle.

(g) A statement as to whether the customer is being charged according to a flat rate or an hourly rate, or both.

(h) The estimated cost of repair which shall include any charge for shop supplies or for hazardous or other waste removal and, if a charge is included, the estimate shall include the following statement:

"This charge represents costs and profits to the motor vehicle repair facility for miscellaneous shop supplies or waste disposal."

If a charge is mandated by state or federal law, the estimate shall contain a statement identifying the law and the specific amount charged under the law.

(i) The charge for making a repair price estimate or, if the charge cannot be predetermined, the basis on which the charge will be calculated.

(j) The customer's intended method of payment.

(k) The name and telephone number of another person who may authorize repair work, if the customer desires to designate such person.

(l) A statement indicating what, if anything, is guaranteed in connection with the repair work and the time and mileage period for which the guarantee is effective.

(m) A statement allowing the customer to indicate whether replaced parts should be saved for inspection or return.

(n) A statement indicating the daily charge for storing the customer's motor vehicle after the customer has been notified that the repair work has been completed. However, no storage charges shall accrue or be due and payable for a period of 3 working days from the date of such notification.

(2) If the cost of repair work will exceed $100, the shop shall present to the customer a written notice conspicuously disclosing, in a separate, blocked section, only the following statement, in capital letters of at least 12-point type:

PLEASE READ CAREFULLY, CHECK ONE OF THE STATEMENTS BELOW, AND SIGN:

I UNDERSTAND THAT, UNDER STATE LAW, I AM ENTITLED TO A WRITTEN ESTIMATE IF MY FINAL BILL WILL EXCEED $100.

_____ I REQUEST A WRITTEN ESTIMATE.

_____ I DO NOT REQUEST A WRITTEN ESTIMATE AS LONG AS THE REPAIR COSTS DO NOT EXCEED $_____. THE SHOP MAY NOT EXCEED THIS AMOUNT WITHOUT MY WRITTEN OR ORAL APPROVAL.

_____ I DO NOT REQUEST A WRITTEN ESTIMATE.

SIGNED _______________

DATE _____

(3) The information required by paragraphs (1)(h) and (i) need not be provided if the customer waives in writing her or his right to receive a written estimate.

(4) Except as provided in subsection (5), a copy of the written repair estimate required by subsection (1) and the disclosure statement required by subsection (2) shall be given to the customer before repair work is begun. The disclosure statement may be provided on the same form as the written repair estimate.

(5) If the customer leaves her or his motor vehicle at a motor vehicle repair shop during hours when the shop is not open or if the customer permits the shop or another person to deliver the motor vehicle to the shop, there shall be an implied partial waiver of the written estimate; however, upon completion of diagnostic work necessary to estimate the cost of repair, the shop shall notify the customer as required in s. 559.909(1).

(6) Nothing in this section shall be construed to require a motor vehicle repair shop to give a written estimated price if the motor vehicle repair shop does not agree to perform the requested repair.

For a consumer lawyer in your area, go to

http://naca.networkats.com/members_online/members/directorya.asp?token=

Want to know the law? Sign up for our free newsletter on varies areas of the law by sending an email to [email protected] and requesting the newsletter, or go to www.ConsumerLawyerHelp.com. See www.FL-PI-Lawyer.com for your personal injury needs.

Read more
Answered on 12/20/10, 10:15 am


Related Questions & Answers

More General Civil Litigation questions and answers in Florida