Legal Question in Immigration Law in Florida

I sent out the I-410 petition and now got a RFE to ask my sponsoer A,inc ability to pay. The 2008 tax return for A, inc didn't look good only has about $7000 on it but previous years looks ok (from 2000~2007). Do I have a good argument here we have the $7000 in 2008 because of the recession? (Its a hotel management company and the hotel industry in Orlando got impact very bad by economy/high gas price issue in 2008). What else documents I can use to support my argument for the ability to pay? Owner's personal financial statement? A,inc's bank statements? A,inc's operation capital? Please help! thank you!


Asked on 8/01/09, 7:04 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Marc Seguinot Seguinot & Associates, P.C.

First of all, your petitioner is the one who should be worrying about this, not you, eh? If you are saying that he only showed a net profit of $7000, if it is not enough to add another salary, it won't make it. However, he should respond to the RFE with whatever information he has, including a good explanation for the low net proceeds. A few things you have not mentioned: what kind of work is it that you have been offered, and what is the prevailing wage for the position. Next, how long has the business been in operation -- sounds like this type of company, hotel management, has probably been around for quite awhile. I don't understand the very low $7000. So, as I said -- respond to the RFE. Should the I-140 be denied, it is highly likely that you will get a second chance before the Immigration Judge. Good luck!

Read more
Answered on 8/01/09, 7:13 pm
Michael Harris Law Offices of Kravitz and Guerra, P.A.

It is true that the initial inquiry will be what is your offered salary. If the tax returns do not look good, there may a reason why, and there may be other formulas (based on Immigration Law) which may provide more of a favorable outlook. That is, net income is not the only factor.

It is very important that you or your employer seek a competent immigration attorney. You do not want to wait for a denial. The RFE will be your best chance. If the I-140 is denied (as well as any underlying I-485 application) -- and you do not have non-immigrant status (e.g. H-1B or L-1, etc.) -- then you could be issued a Notice To Appear ("NTA") before an Immigration Judge ("IJ"). Your first option would be to file an appeal with the USCIS Service Center -- so an NTA may not happen and you may not be called before an IJ. So, please be aware that depending on what your situation is, you may not be called before an IJ upon denial of your petition (as the above attorney noted).

Read more
Answered on 8/04/09, 9:50 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Immigration Law questions and answers in Florida