Legal Question in Real Estate Law in Florida
Property lien, work ordered by potential buyer
Situation: house for sale, buyer (represented by realtor) enters into a contract for purchase of house with contingency that buyer can build an additional structure on property. Buyer orders architectural services, including survey, preliminary drawings and representation before the deed-restricted community's architectural review board. Buyer defaults on contract for purchase of house, having made no deposits to escrow and no payments for architectural services. Architect subsequently sends Notice to Owner stating services were ordered by "potential buyer," then threatens owner with construction lien if owner does not pay for architectural services in full, including a retainer fee the architect did not collect from the potential buyer. Question: Can the architect attach a lien on the property, even though services were not contracted by the property owner?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Property lien, work ordered by potential buyer
Based upon the information provide, the architect can file a lien. It will probably be invalid. I suggest the lien be bonded off and demand be made to the architect to bring suit within 60 days or lose all rights. I am not addressing other remedies that may be available to the owner. You should consult with an attorney. If you are in my vicinity, call me at 305-940-8080.
The reason for bonding off the lien is to shorten the time for the architect to act and to avoid a claim for attorney fees to the substantial prevailing party in an action to foreclose the lien.
Alexander M. Rosenfeld
Rosenfeld & Stein, P.A.
18260 NE 19 Ave
Property lien for work ordered by non-owner.
Q. House for sale, buyer enters into a contract
for purchase with contingency that buyer can build
an additional structure. Buyer orders architectural
services. Buyer defaults on contract having made
no deposits to escrow and no payments for
architectural services. Architect sends Notice to
Owner stating services were ordered by "potential
buyer," then threatens owner with construction
lien if owner does not pay for architectural
services in full, including a retainer fee not
collected from the buyer. Can the architect
attach a lien on the property, even though services
were not contracted by the property owner?
A. The architect can file a lien; that does not
mean he will be sucessful in enforcing it. You can
file a notice of contest and force him to either
file suit or give up his "claim of lien". Normally
only an owner or HIS AUTHORIZED AGENT can contract
for work done on the land. The owners involvement
would be a factor to consider. The owner can
counterclaim for fraudulent lien and sue the architect.
No owner should sigh a contract without getting a
sizeable deposit. Neither should a architect do
work without a deposit retainer.
William W. Fernandez
William W. Fernandez, Attorney at Law
250 Panama Road East