Legal Question in Wills and Trusts in Florida

Can you please tell me if a will can be contested in Florida? My mother's will was created in Ohio in 1980.

It has my youngest brother at 40% me at 40% and my two other brothers at 10% each.

My mother passed away last year. I took care of her for over 10 years while my brothers chose to not be in her life or mine.

She died under very suspicious circumstances that are now being investigated.

So there can possibly be a lawsuit if wrongful death enters picture.

So I would like to know if I can contest the will based on my siblings turing their back on her for years .

I understand they will divide it all evenly but I feel I would like to contest it based on their non involvement in her life.

I feel if they must get a percentage it should be very low.

Please tell me if this is possible. The will is an Ohio one and is not notorized. I contacted the original law firm and apparently does not have to be notarized and they told me it could be contested.

Thank you so much for your help.


Asked on 2/27/11, 9:33 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Any Will can be contested, but you must have grounds. The grounds that they were not involved in her life are not valid grounds. It happens all the time. Inheritances are not determined by worthwhile lifetime points earned with the decedent. But solely what the decedent wants to devise (which may not make sense to anyone else).

Valid grounds for contesting a Will are undue influence when she made the Will, diminished capacity when she made the Will, or invalid execution when she signed the Will. None of those appear to be present.

If you successfully contest the Will, unless there is the possibility of even an older Will that could be used, then the law would require each sibling to receive 25% each. So that would work against you, not in your favor. You would lose 15%.

Now as to the suspicious circumstances of her death. If it is determined that her cause of death was murder from a beneficiary, then that beneficiary would be treated as if they had predeceased the person they murdered. Their share (depending upon the Will) would either go to their lineal descendents (most likely), or would lapse (if the Will provided so).

By the way, the Will will have to be proved up to be admitted into court.

Hope this helps.

Read more
Answered on 2/27/11, 9:52 am
Lucreita Becude Lucreita D. Becude, P.A.

Mr. Kaplan is absolutely correct. If you wish to pursue the wrongful death, and you are located in my area please don't hesitate to contact my office for an appointment.

Read more
Answered on 2/27/11, 12:12 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Probate, Trusts, Wills & Estates questions and answers in Florida