Legal Question in Civil Litigation in Idaho
How do I get at least part of my childrens money back?
My house was broken into and all the money in my kids piggy banks was taken. A 15 yr. old boy who lives on my street was seen by 4 neighbors carrying my 10 yr. old daughters screen from her window to his house. All of the neighbors filled out statements with the police. Fingerprints were taken from the window by the police. They went to the boy's house to question him and the father wouldn't allow them to. He agreed to bring his son in for "elimination" fingerprints two weeks ago, and still hasn't (I doubt he will). The police say there is nothing they can do because he "wasn't caught" in my house, and that if the father doesn't bring him in they cant get fingerprints. There was a minimum of 300$ taken, plus the screen. Since the police cant (or won't) do anything, can I take this to small claims court? Since the boy is a juvenile would I name the father as a defendant? With statements from 4 adults, isn't that reason enough for a juvenile to be brought in for fingerprinting with or without parental approval? Thank you for your time.
2 Answers from Attorneys
Seek help from the Courts
You can contact the district attorney or the police chief about the failure of the police to investigate.
You can also contact the state attorney general. You may be able to initiate a criminal complaint at the
local court or file a small claims action. For these last two you can talk to the clerk of the local court.
Alan Pransky
Law Office of Alan J. Pransky
20 Eastbrook Road
Re: How do I get my children's money back?
Wow. I disagree with the police; I think they can
arrest him and then get his fingerprints, or get a
warrant for the fingerprints before they arrest him
if they feel more comfortable.
Believe it or not, you can apply to a judge yourself
for such a warrant. (You'd then use a sheriff or
constable to get them, with or without his cooperation.)
You could even bring the criminal charges against him
yourself, even if the police didn't feel that they
could, though I don't recommend it. However, it's good
for bluff value. If you go to the court for the warrant,
and they try to defend, keep in mind that the father may
not speak for the child -- only lawyers may do that, and
you object if he tries. (You'll lose that objection, but
you could appeal it.) He's supposed to hire an attorney
which would cost them more than $300 (but they'd win that
particular proceeding because attorneys beat lay people
usually). I'm not sure the child (or father) has a right
even to be there, though, as warrants are generally obtained
"ex parte."
But I've digressed. There are probably less legal and more
practical ways to solve it. Send pops a note telling him what
a rain of legal greif you will shower down upon them if you don't
get $$ back, and then offer to keep the payment private, if he
makes it, so that it won't be an admission of guilt. It all depends
on what you really want ... the $300 or a convinction.
You can probably get the court to order the police to execute the
warrant for you, by the way, and save a few steps. My guess is that
Dad wants to keep his son from looking like the crook that he is while
he straightens the kid out, preserving his reputation and keeping his
record clean. But juvenile justice laws have their own way of doing
that within the legal system, so I say, fire away!
By the way, this is not my area of law, I've never done these things,
and ... well, you shouldn't rely upon any of my
statements in this matter. I do better with other
areas!
Stuart Williams
Law Offices of Stuart J. Williams
21 Walter St.