Legal Question in Wills and Trusts in Illinois
My family and I would like to sue to acquire the remains of my brother that died in a 2008 house fire. The remains of my brother after being cremated have been in the possession of my sister in law. Now here is where it gets tricky. My brother and sister in law, at the time of his death, were separated, going through a divorce, because of infidelity that she committed. She is not carrying out the wishes of my brother, who wanted to have his ashes scattered, she is simply holding onto them, and has made it clear that she does not intend to honor his wishes. Short of kicking in her door and taking my brother's remains back with force, what options do my family and I have? My brother had no written will, but communicated his wishes of what he wanted years before he was married. With the fact that they were separated, living in different dwellings, and proceeding with a divorce, do I have founds to sue for his remains? If not, what can I do?
1 Answer from Attorneys
As there is no will, the most likely course of action you'd have to take is to open up what's called an "intestate" probate estate in probate court in your area. One of you would have to be named administrator (the "executor" for such an estate) and so forth. If there was a pending divorce with any kind of order establishing a "legal" separation that may be important, and possibly helpful but until reviewed in whole is an unknown (if they were just living apart with no order of separate maintenance, etc., there was always the chance for reconciliation....) and technically they were still married even though on filing for divorce property held in joint ownership deemed converted to tenancy-in-common to prevent problems with inheritance. But you're opening up a can of worms that will be costly and time-consuming. If she is vindictive (doesn't sound like it but just stir the pot and see what happens) she might just dispose of those remains if you threaten or file any kind of legal action. Since there are missing components here, you should probably discuss the entire fact situation with a probate attorney in your area. Point is before pulling the trigger get your information and if the probate attorney confirms what I'm suggesting, the way to start this out may be to open some lines of communication. You can try this on your own, or you might want to try through a third party -- could be a shared friend, clergy, attorney.... You may wind up having to compromise.....be prepared. But good luck.