Legal Question in Criminal Law in India
Discharge 227 IPC
What is the difference between ''Quashing (u/s482)'' and ''Discharge (u/s227)''? In a rape case can the court give discharge? Can the case still be taken forward (by the complainant or investigating authority)after a discharge is allowed?
4 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Discharge 227 IPC
Result of Discharge and Quashing is same viz. acquittal of accused.
However, in Discharge, Court need to presume that everything alleged against accused is correct and still no prima facie case is made out.
While in Quashing, the High Court has extra ordinary powers and can look into other factors like abuse of process of law etc.
Re: Discharge 227 IPC
An aggrieved party may challenge an order of discharge before the next higher court in accordance with the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code.
Re: Discharge 227 IPC
The result of discharge and qashing is same if there is only one accused. In case of more than one accused the court has discharged only one accused the matter will contiue in respect of the other accused whereas in case of quashing the matter is quashed and both the accused are discharged.
Yes the accused if innocent will be discharged by the court with instruction to the authorities to investigate the matter further.
Though, I fail to understand that in a rape case the accused is being accused of rape only on the basis of the statement of the complainant. Hence I feel the question of discharge may not arise unless there is ambiguity in the mind of the complainant.
Re: Discharge 227 IPC
Against the discharge complainant can file an Appeal in high court.
But in quashing case is completely closed.
Regards
Kamal Grover
Advocate
Chandigarh
For more query plz feel free, contact
M:09814110005
adv.kamal.grover/gmail.com
We deal all over India and fight for your Rights.
Related Questions & Answers
-
498A and bail I am a doctor working in UK, my wife has filed a 498A case against me... Asked 5/16/09, 10:54 pm in India Criminal Law
-
Fir against husband hI, I have been living with my parents for the last 1.2 years as... Asked 5/15/09, 10:04 pm in India Criminal Law
-
Cheque bouns i give 90000 rs to my friend in cash and he give a cheque of same... Asked 5/15/09, 11:14 am in India Criminal Law
-
Anticipatory bail application thorugh Power of Attorney sir, i want to know that... Asked 5/15/09, 10:29 am in India Criminal Law