Legal Question in Credit and Debt Law in Iowa
I'd read that based on a 1989 Iowa court case that funds in a bank account are exempt from garnishment if they are from wages that are direct deposited and have already been garnished. Does this mean my wifes paycheck that is direct deposited is safe since it was already garnished or can they still take it? I just want to make sure I understood the court decision correctly. This is the information on the case I'm referring to.
Under MidAmerica SavBank v. Miehe, 438 N.W.2d 837 (Iowa, 1989), �personal earnings exempt from garnishment under section 642.21, which can be traced to checking account or savings account in a financial institution, continue to be exempt from creditors� levies. This holding applies to both pay period limitation and the calendar year limitation contained in section 642.21. Because the purpose of allowing wages to retain their exempt character is to facilitate payment of ordinary living expenses, the continuation of exempt status is conditioned upon tracing the deposits from wages received within a ninety-day period preceding the levy.�
1 Answer from Attorneys
You're probably correct but I would think that the problem you would have is that once you become someone who's being garnished the banks lose all friendliness that they might have had to you. If they've already given the money to the garnishor you have to go to court, file a motion, serve it, show up for court, and then get the court to order the funds released. Then, you have to have what the President calls a "teaching moment" with the bank, because they really are not knowledgeable about debtor creditor law and couldn't care less anyway.
Of course that case may have been modified, augmented, discussed or rejected, and I do not have any way here to Shepardize it.
Here's some general information I prepared a couple of years ago. I hope this is of use to you.
Federal law governs wage garnishment for debt.
Wages and accounts may be garnished.
Each creditor must apply to the court for a writ of execution and that writ is served on someone who owes you money-in this case, your employer, or in the case of a bank account garnishment, the bank where your money is deposited.
Certain income is exempt from garnishment-pension, social security, SSI, disability.
Also, if accounts are garnished, the garnishor is limited to money that has been in the account longer than ninety days, which presumably means it is wages. In practice banks do not observe these limitations-the normal practice is to take ALL the money and let you try and figure it out. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn�t.
Sometimes, under Iowa law we may see a debtor examination which is a legal proceeding whereby a debtor is sworn under oath to disclose the location of assets. It is rarely used and I have never seen it or heard of it being done in 11 years of practice.
Disposable earnings are earnings after taxes and social security, and unemployment insurance have been deducted. Health and Dental insurance, life insurance, charitable contributions and other payments are NOT exempt from garnishment.
Maximum amounts:
The maximum that may be garnished in any pay period (regardless of how many garnishment orders are received by the employer) is limited to the LESSER of two amounts-either 25 per cent of your disposable earnings OR the amount by which disposable earnings are greater than 30 times the Federal minimum wage, which is $5.85 per hour.
Let�s assume that your biweekly check is $1,300.
That would be $604 weekly (2,600/4.3)
604 x .25 = $151 maximum garnishment weekly
$5.85 x 30 = $175.50
We go with the lower figure for the week.
You may apply to the court for an exemption of more money from garnishment if the money is for the support of your family.
Maximum amount for any calendar year is on a sliding scale from $250 per creditor per year to 10 per cent of the annual wages per creditor, not per judgment under Iowa Code �642.21
Section �D� below suggests that if your annual income is $35,000 or more, you can expect that any one creditor may garnish $2,000 of your wages in any one year.
642.21 EXEMPTION FROM NET EARNINGS.
1. The disposable earnings of an individual are exempt from
garnishment to the extent provided by the federal Consumer Credit
Protection Act, Title III, 15 U.S.C. secs. 1671--1677 (1982). The
maximum amount of an employee's earnings which may be garnished
during any one calendar year is two hundred fifty dollars for each
judgment creditor, except as provided in chapter 252D and sections
598.22, 598.23, and 627.12, or when those earnings are reasonably
expected to be in excess of twelve thousand dollars for that calendar
year as determined from the answers taken by the sheriff or by the
court pursuant to section 642.5, subsection 4. When the employee's
earnings are reasonably expected to be more than twelve thousand
dollars the maximum amount of those earnings which may be garnished
during a calendar year for each creditor is as follows:
a. Employees with expected earnings of twelve thousand
dollars or more, but less than sixteen thousand dollars, not more
than four hundred dollars may be garnished.
b. Employees with expected earnings of sixteen thousand
dollars or more, but less than twenty-four thousand dollars, not more
than eight hundred dollars may be garnished.
c. Employees with expected earnings of twenty-four thousand
dollars or more, but less than thirty-five thousand dollars, not more
than one thousand five hundred dollars may be garnished.
d. Employees with expected earnings of thirty-five thousand
dollars or more, but less than fifty thousand dollars, not more than
two thousand dollars may be garnished.
e. Employees with expected earnings of fifty thousand dollars
or more, not more than ten percent of an employee's expected
earnings