Legal Question in Technology Law in Maryland

Invalid "REMOVE" e-mail address on spam e-mail

Most spam that I have recieved lately, in theory, complies with whatever law they say is out there requiring that all unsolicited e-mail must have a way to get taken off of the list, and therefor not recieve any more spam. However, when I try to reply to this email with "REMOVE" in the subject or whatever, my mail gets returned; that address is not known, or invalid for some other reason. I realize that they are technically complying with the statute by providing an address at all, but can they be pursued legally if the address is invalid? (one would think that the spirit of the law would mean a valid address) and if I were to sue someone like that, would I be able to get any money out of it? I figure that enough people are pissing me off by sending me spam, so I might as well make some money off of it! :) Thanks for your help!


Asked on 8/18/99, 9:32 am

3 Answers from Attorneys

Timothy J. Walton Internet Attorney

Re: Spam

Just because a spammer provides a "remove" address does not mean it is in full compliance with the law. The California statute, for example, has a number of other requirements besides a valid remove address. However, I am not aware of any law in Maryland that regulates spam.

If you can figure out who sent you spam, then absolutely you can sue. Whether you win will depend upon a number of factors.

If you are serious about suing spammers, contact me at [email protected] or take a look at http://www.netatty.com/spam.html

Read more
Answered on 8/19/99, 10:37 pm
Timothy J. Walton Internet Attorney

Re: Spam

Since my earlier post, I have learned that Mayland has had a law since 1998 which regulates unsolicited email, but only if that email is harassing. Ordinary UCE (unsolicited commercial email) does not appear to be covered.

I am not licensed in Maryland, nor have a studied the statute or cases interpreting it.

Still, if the UCE originates in a state where it is in violation of the law, then you could file suit in that state. Defense attorneys call this "forum shopping." The problem is that while a defendant's home state will always have jurisdiction, it may have a choice of law provision that chooses the law of the forum where the injury occurred. This would essentially put you back in Maryland, but with an out-of-state attorney.

Read more
Answered on 8/20/99, 2:22 am
Bruce Burdick Burdick Law Firm

Re: Invalid

I suggest you drop your pipe dream about getting rich sueing spammers and just use your email filter.

You probably would spend more than you win and probably would not be able to collect anything even if you did win. Only if you find a deep pocket spammer would the suit be profitable, and the ones with the deep pockets generally spam in a legal manner with valid unsubscribe information.

Read more
Answered on 8/20/99, 12:57 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Computer & Technology Law questions and answers in Maryland