Legal Question in Criminal Law in Massachusetts
possible assault & battery
If you use minimal force to remove someone from your property and they file an a&b charge, can you use the Castle Doctrine? What is the liklihood for a person with a clean record to serve time for an a&b?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: possible assault & battery
The answer to your first question is that it depends on the circumstances. You need to provide more details in order to get an accurate answer. With respect to your second question, I agree with what Attorney Maloney has said.
Re: possible assault & battery
Use of minimal force is allowed to remove a trespasser from your property. However, without knowing the exact circumstances, it is impossible to determine if it would be a viable defense in a given case.
With regard to your second question, it is very unlikely that someone with no record would serve time in MA for an A&B. Really, the only reason it should occur would be if there were serious injuries sustained by the victim.
One caveat to this however, is that under Chapter 265 of Mass. Law, a conviction after a jury trial for A&B has the presumption of a jail sentence and the judge has to file written findings if a person is not sentenced to jail after a jury trial on that charge.
If you have any further questions, please feel free to contact me.
Related Questions & Answers
-
Stop payment on a check the appraiser is threatening to prosecute me Asked 8/11/07, 2:14 pm in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law