Legal Question in Criminal Law in Massachusetts

False Accusation

Recently I was charged with Larceny over $250. The plaintiff in this matter called an Officer of the law and made accusations against me that I had stolen his laptop. I never got notified by a police officer regarding this accusation, just a summons to appear in court for this matter. Today was my arraignment and I was asked by the judge to hire a lawyer. My question is, How can someone point the finger and accuse another person of Larceny based on accusations? Last time I checked Larceny over $250 is considered a felony, the commonwealth of Massachusetts took it in there hands to make this a criminal case. If everyone could just point fingers and accuse someone of Larceny, there would be a lot of people with felony's. Possession is 9/10th's of the law and with no evidence, How is a judge suppose to make a verdict?


Asked on 12/16/08, 2:21 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

Michael Bace Bace Law Group, LLC

Re: False Accusation

I can understand your frustration. However, the State has a duty to continue to prosecute you if they have sufficient evidence to do so. The only way to be vindicated is to defend the charges.

The most important course of action is to hire an attorney immediately. Criminal accusations of any scope are serious, and can have equally as serious repercussions.

An attorney, licensed in the Commonwealth, can prepare your defense, and ensure that your rights are protected at every stage of the proceedings.

Feel free to contact me to discuss further.

Read more
Answered on 12/16/08, 2:26 pm

Re: False Accusation

You are understandably upset, but this is a time when you should be cautious. Right now you stand accused of a crime and a conviction can have serious consequences.

The way the law is written in massachusetts, there is no requirement that any PROOF of a crime be offered to police in order to file an accusation. For political reasons (our prosecutors are elected) all accusations are treated as if they are true until they are disproven. People who are accused must go to court and have a criminal record opened against them... a record that remians, permanently, even if they are found to be not guilty, or even if the prosecuion dismisses the charges.

Trials are the place where guilt or innocence are determined, not arraignments, so it is important that you have a good criminal defense attorney represent you. You have a life, a family and a job to worry about protecting.

Read more
Answered on 12/16/08, 2:55 pm
Gregory Casale Gregory Casale Attorney At Law

Re: False Accusation

In order to issue a complaint for any charge, there needs to be probable cause. Apparently the Clerk Magistrate thought that whatever investigation the police officer conducted provided sufficient probable cause to issue the complaint. It is a much lower standard of proof for probable cause (more likely than not) than it is to convict you (beyond a resonable doubt). Since it is a serious charge, the judge wisely advised you to hire an attorney. I too strongly recommend that you hire a good Criminal Defense Attorney and fight the charge.

Read more
Answered on 12/16/08, 4:27 pm
Joseph Murray Joseph M. Murray, Esq.

Re: False Accusation

Retain an attorney to defend you and speak only with that attorney about this. If you are found not guilty and that attorney determines that there was not even probable cause to have issued the complaint against you, your attorney can advise as to your possible remedies. Good Luck!

Read more
Answered on 12/16/08, 5:34 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in Massachusetts