Legal Question in Criminal Law in Massachusetts
In massachusetts if the police say that the person arrested made a statement at the time of arrest, but there is no signed statement, no signed away miranda rights, and no audio/video statement made can just the police officers word fly in court?
2 Answers from Attorneys
The police can testify about statements made by the defendant just like any other witness. The weight given by the jury to the testimony of the officer can be effected by lack of miranda statements, etc.
The administration and waiver of Miranda warnings impacts the admissibility of the alleged statement. However, Miranda is only required when the suspect is both in custody AND subject to interrogation; things that the person said but not in response to any question are not subject to Miranda.
As for the lack of a written signed statement or audio/video recording of the alleged statement, the absence of a writing or a recording goes to the weight of the evidence but not to it's admissibility. The police can testify that the person made the statement without having to produce a writing or a recording.
Note that voluntariness, or lack thereof, of the statement is another separate but related prerequisite for the admission of a person's statement.
Related Questions & Answers
-
If i was told by the judge to attend anger management but it wasnt on my docket Asked 3/24/11, 12:41 pm in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law