Legal Question in Criminal Law in Massachusetts
prof respons
If a lawyer is called in an emergency to represent a person (not a current client) at a bail hearing and the ''client'' tells the lawyer that the reason he wants to get out is to commit a crime, is is unethical for the lawyer to assist this ''client''?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: prof respons
You are using words for which the legal significance is presumed. A bail hearing is a specialized procedure, and the goal is whether the person can be released on personal recognizance or on payment of bail to assure their return.
Re: prof respons
When you say the person "wants to get out to commit a crime," I don't know what you mean they want to do, but I think the whole scenario puts the attorney in a very difficult position. There are two components to calculating the amount of bail: (1) whether the defendant is likely to appear in court on the next scheduled date, and (2) the likelihood that the defendant will present a danger to the community if released. Both elements are part of a bail determination. If the "crime" the person wants to commit involves an element of danger to the community, I don't know how the attorney could assist the defendant in the bail hearing without compromising effectiveness, ethics, or both.
Related Questions & Answers
-
Refile complaint. Can I refile or appeal a complaint to superior court that was... Asked 11/20/08, 10:30 am in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law
-
Record of restraining order I called a lawyer for some advice on one issue, and... Asked 11/19/08, 6:50 pm in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law
-
Criminal record how long does a drunk drivings stay on your criminal record Asked 11/17/08, 11:35 am in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law
-
Missed court date he was picked up on a warrant for missing a court date, on a... Asked 11/14/08, 7:57 am in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law