Legal Question in Criminal Law in Massachusetts
Rape Case Question
A girl in my building has accused me of rape, I did not do it, have a lawyer etc. But my question, she keeps asking me when I see her in the foyer how I am doing? And she tries to have converstations with me, I just say fine and keep on walking. Do I have any rights? I just feel like she feels bad or is trying to set me up. What should I do when she tries to talk to me? Should I keep walking and say nothing? I want her to leave me alone until this mess is over.
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Rape Case Question
I disagree with the previous reply. Just yesterday, a jury found a client of mine Not Guilty of Parental Kidnapping,
That client talked to the press continually, and was even interviewed on Channel 4's Eye-Team (CBS Boston) by Joe Bergantino.
The cure is to ask the jury if anyone was swayed one way or the other by the publicity.
As to her speaking to you: Ask your lawyer to get a protective order for you. There are several kinds: one is an abuse prevention order, which is available to you if you had been in an intimate dating relationship.
If that does not work, your counsel can possibly bring a civil assault action against her. She has put you in fear. Do not try to do this alone. To do this, certain circumstances must exist. You will have to fill in some gaps for your lawyer.
You might also consider carrying a mini-taperecorder with you,
ready to turn on the moment she approaches you.
Be careful. This, too, must be done in a special way . . .
so that you do not violate the "wiretap" law,
which in Massachusetts requires both parties to
know about the recording.
If she speaks to you,you will have it recorded. Immediately ask, "Do you mind if I tape this?"
If she says Yes, then record.
If she says No, say, "Then I'm turning this recorder off."
In that way, you have a record that she spoke first and what she said.
The defense to a charge of tape-recording is that the taping was not done in SECRET.
What you did was not SECRET. Given that she has accused you of rape, she should have NO REASONABLE EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY.
She must show that she EXPECTED PRIVACY when she spoke to you. That would be unrealistic or UNreasonable given that she has caused a criminal action to be initiated against you.
Good luck!!
Barbara
--
Barbara C. Johnson, Advocate of Court Reform and Attorney at Law
6 Appletree Lane
Andover, MA 01810-4102
978-474-0833
Committee to Elect Barbara C. Johnson for Governor
P.O. Box 1863
Andover, MA 01810
Campaign for Governor: http://www.barbforgovernor.com
False Allegations: http://www.falseallegations.com
Participating Attorney:
http://www.lawguru.com/cgi/bbs2/user/browse.shtml
-----
The judicial system is very broken. It must be fixed.
There are four people who can do the job:
Everybody, Somebody, Anybody, and Nobody.
Everybody thinks Somebody will surely do it.
It is a job Anybody can do. But Nobody is doing it.
At least I'm trying. What are you doing?
Re: Rape Case Question
You should not be posting any questions in a public place when you have charges pending against you. These could be used against you in your criminal case. Any questions you have should be asked of your lawyer, and no one else.
This is really important. There are not that many Rape cases being prosecuted in this county, and you could be identified from the information you included. The consequences if you are found guilty are very serious. Speak only with your lawyer about this.
Tom
Related Questions & Answers
-
Probation forcing patients off methadone! legal or not? I have a very simple... Asked 5/09/02, 11:58 am in United States Massachusetts Criminal Law