Legal Question in Immigration Law in Massachusetts

citizenship - immigration

I became an American citizen last year. I got my certificate of naturalization, my passport and i also changed my personal info with a social security office. Receantly, when i tried to sign up for a class in a community college, I was asked to proof that i am a citizen. Why can't they check my status by my social security number? My friend who is an american born in US only showed her driver's license, why do i need to have an extra proof since i am also an american citizen? Will i always have to show my sertificate or passport in additoin to my id? Will I always be asked for a proof of my citizenship, because i am not a native of this country and people can hear my accent?

Thank you


Asked on 9/27/08, 5:24 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Melina Merino Attorney Melina Merino

Re: citizenship - immigration

It will depend on the institution and what are you applying for. It is usually the person's responsibility to show proof of citizenship (or valid work authorization or legal status), not the institution (just because you have a social security number doesn't necessarily mean you are a US citizen). For example, many employers ask for I-9 verification, even to citizens who were born in the USA. When applying for a passport, even US born citizens are sometimes given the run-around with the documents like birth certificates, etc. to prove their citizenship. Don't take it personal- many times institutions give a hard time to everyone, including citizens born in US soil!

Read more
Answered on 9/27/08, 5:54 pm
Marc Seguinot Seguinot & Associates, P.C.

Re: citizenship - immigration

You do not have to carry your certificate of naturalization, of course not. And someday most of us citizens will have to carry our passport in our back pockets, but until then, there is no reason that the school cannot check -- they are able to check on student statuses, no reason they can't check your status. They are simply lazy. If I could take time right now, in the state of MA, I would probably advise the school that your naturalization as a citizen does not give anyone the right to now treat you different from a citizen born in this country. Maybe you ought to give them a jolt -- I will bet if you told them you were being treated unequally, they may think about what they are doing. Lastly, ask them to show you the regulations that requires more than a driver's license to prove eligibility to register for classes. Sorry I am not in MA, but this would have been an interesting case. Take care and I understand your frustration.

Read more
Answered on 9/27/08, 9:54 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Immigration Law questions and answers in Massachusetts